The latest episode of Yellowstone featured the death of the Dutton family's patriarch, John Dutton. The show also built some intrigue around who is responsible for his staged suicide in the Governor's office. The show comes with a compelling story for Kayce, Beth, and Jamie, with the rest of the ranch. But, indeed, the narrative lives alongside Costner and his character.
The major reasons behind Costner's exit were significant creative and scheduling conflicts between Costner and the production team. This is because, currently Costner is involved in his personal film Horizon, which is clashing with Yellowstone's date. These challenges led to a shortened conclusion for John Dutton's arc and, ultimately, the series' conclusion. Read further to explore in detail why Yellowstone had to end with Kevin Costner's exit.
Why Yellowstone had to end with Kevin Costner's exit?
John's murder set all the stories to an end in the Dutton family. According to Sheridan, he has always thought of John Dutton's death as a precursor to the show's finale. Therefore, his exit has rightly fast-tracked the show.
However, John's death has not been explicitly explored in the series, but the finale gives a significant screentime to the funeral. It would not be surprising even if the series would have continued to exist after season 5, keeping in mind the popularity of the show. But the narrative lives and dies by Kevin Costner and his character.
Season 5, part 2 also seemed rushed as it had only 6 episodes to tie all the stories together, but extending the show for one more season without John would have been a wrong decision. The show should've lost its soul without the family's patriarch.
Despite the interesting stories of individual characters, John Dutton and the ranch were important connecting dots for all the lingering stories. Therefore, the show without John would have appeared scattered. Creator Taylor Sheridan opted to wrap the show and focus on expanding the franchise by creating Yellowstone spin-offs like 1923 and 6666 and keeping the Dutton legacy alive.
Kevin Costner has always been vocal about his appreciation for the show. In June 2024, the actor expressed his feelings through an Instagram post:
"It was something that really changed me. I loved it and I know you loved it. And I just wanted to let you know that I won't be returning,” he explained. “I love the relationship that we've been able to develop, and I'll see you at the movies."