"Why did you get her": The Voice fans react to Michael Bublé bringing in Cynthia Erivo as 'Battle Advisor'

Talent, surprises, and a little controversy have always been a part of The Voice, and Season 27 is no exception.

With the official announcement coming from the social media handles of The Voice on March 22, 2025, fans are split on Michael Bublé's decision to have American singer and actress Cynthia Erivo as a 'Battle Advisor' for the 'Battles' round this season. Erivo appeared in episode 8, which was aired on the 24th of this month. Her involvement has, in fact, generated quite an online debate. Some criticize the decision, while others praise it, given her knowledge of music, which underscores the nuanced dynamics of celebrity mentoring in such contests.

Erivo, fresh from her acclaimed role in Wicked (2024) and on the brink of playing Jesus Christ in an upcoming production, brings a unique blend of theatrical expertise and vocal mastery to the show. Her mentorship has been considered as nothing short of a musical masterclass, offering the contestants insights that go beyond typical reality show guidance.

Fans of The Voice react to Cynthia Erivo’s special appearance

The responses on social media to Erivo's mentorship have been a complex mix of admiration and criticism. Cynthia Erivo's casting as Jesus in Jesus Christ Superstar has sparked mixed reactions, which, in turn, has influenced how fans view her mentorship.

“Why did you get her. Now I have to fast forward through your parts on the voice. She is playing Jesus Christ Superstar. Bad.” one fan commented on X.com

“Used to be my favorite judge no longer.” another fan commented.

“That woman should not play Jesus though it’s blasphemy Jesus Christ is a man period not a woman not a woman trying to be a woman or visa versa a man and fully god in essence and nature half and half.” another netizen said.

However, some fans laud her musical prowess, calling her an "unbelievable singer" with a talent that "does not come around often."

“I could never in a million years sing in front of Mrs Erivo. Fainting I could do.” another fan commented.

“Team buble always to win” a fan said on X.com

“What a 'Wicked' combo-if I might say so myself!” another fan said.

“Daaaaaamn!!!!!! She’s just an unbelievable singer. Talent like this does not come around often.” another fan commented.

Several fans marveled at the decision to bring to the show someone as experienced in performance as Cynthia is.

“Super cool coaching sessions! Bring The Voice to Canada!!!” another fan said.

“Best judge ever!! Obsessed with her musical mastery! You 2 need to do a duet!!! She needs to play Nina Simone in a movie!!!!” a fan exclaimed on X.com.

“Unpopular opinion: The Voice/Voice Coaches need to bring in more mentors like Kate Hudson and Cynthia Erivo” another fan commented.

Michael Bublé’s decision to choose Cynthia Erivo as a mentor explained

Trained at the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art, Cynthia Erivo's musical journey unfolded to reveal that she is not just a performer but also a technical vocal expert.

Her approach to mentorship mirrors her professional background—precise, challenging, and deeply insightful. As one source noted, she's "not playing with kid gloves" but providing genuine, tough-love guidance that cuts to the core of vocal performance.

The Voice has a history of bringing unexpected mentors to the coaching panel. Previous seasons have featured unique pairings like Snoop Dogg with Simone Biles and Gwen Stefani with Machine Gun Kelly. These choices demonstrate the show's commitment to bringing diverse perspectives to musical mentorship.

The show provides an interesting contrast between Cynthia Erivo and fellow mentor Kate Hudson. While Hudson is primarily known for her acting career, Erivo brings a deep, technical understanding of performance. Collider’s Michael Block describes her mentorship as a "musical masterclass", where contestants are offered detailed insights into vocal technique.

Bublé's selection of Erivo reflects a commitment to high-quality mentorship. Their interactions go beyond skin-deep coaching. Using a hands-on approach uncommon in reality show competitions, Erivo not only advises participants on The Voice but also performs alongside them.

Knowing Erivo and her career trajectory makes it hard to overlook how she might influence the course of The Voice and the music business in general. Even though opinions on her presence on the show are divided, Cynthia Erivo is nevertheless creating history on the show. She differs from other mentors due to her intense involvement, high technical understanding, and capacity to push the competitors beyond their limits.

---

The Voice airs on Mondays at 8 p.m. on NBC. All episodes are available to stream on Peacock.