Why did the creator of MoviePass plead guilty to investor fraud? Details explored 

Theodore Farnsworth, who used to be the CEO of Helios and Matheson Analytics, the company that owns MoviePass, has admitted in court to securities fraud and conspiracy to defraud investors.

This whole mess is because people thought that MoviePass's deal of letting folks watch unlimited movies for just $9.95 a month was a great idea that would make everyone money.

But, as it turns out, the plan was like a flashy trick to get the stock prices to go way up and make investors think the company was golden. The government officials found out that Farnsworth didn't tell the truth about how the company was doing.

Now, the 62-year-old might have to spend up to 25 years in prison—20 for the fraud part and 5 more for being part of a group that was trying to pull one over on the investors.

And it's not just Farnsworth in hot water. His buddy, the former CEO of MoviePass, Mitch Lowe, has also said he's guilty of not being straight with the people who gave them money. If the judge gives them the toughest punishment, Lowe could be looking at spending 5 years behind bars.

Sam Rabin, who is Farnsworth's attorney, said,

“Mr. Farnsworth was anxious to accept responsibility for his conduct.”

This shows that Farnsworth has decided to admit his guilt. This move is monumental in a case that's about MoviePass' shady business activities.

---

MoviePass’ “unlimited” plan was too good to be true

When MoviePass launched in 2017, they shook things up with a deal that seemed too good to be true: for just $9.95 a month, you could watch as many movies in theaters as you wanted. It sounded like a game-changer, right? But, it turns out, it was all a bit of a marketing trick that didn't have the financial legs to stand on.

The people in charge of MoviePass, Farnsworth, and Lowe, told everyone who'd listened that they'd done their homework and that the company would cover its costs, but it turns out that wasn't quite the case. Behind the scenes, their papers showed that they were losing money hand over fist because too many people were taking advantage of the deal.

The prosecution also talked about some shady things they did to keep their losses low. They basically slowed down the service for people who watched a lot of movies, which was a real hassle for those folks. Farnsworth claimed that they had some high-tech AI to make money off user data, but it turns out that was just a bunch of hot air. There was no such thing.

The FBI's Assistant Director James E. Dennehy had something to say about it:

“Farnsworth’s boasts were actually lies designed to boost stock prices.”

He said that all this ended up costing MoviePass investors a whopping $303 million, according to what the government found out.

---

Fraudulent practices at Vinco Ventures

Farnsworth's shady dealings weren't just limited to MoviePass. Between 2020 and 2024, when he was in charge of Vinco Ventures, he got into some serious financial trouble-making. The Department of Justice says he played some tricks to make the company's stock look more valuable than it was.

He didn't just stop there; he was pretty good at hiding his tracks from the folks who are supposed to keep an eye on things like that, namely the regulators and investors. And what did he do with all that money he shouldn't have had? Spent it not on company expenses either - on his shopping spree.

It turns out that Farnsworth's shady behavior didn't just involve money games. Stories began to circulate about him using company cash for his personal affairs and living it up big time, like throwing down $147,000 for a night with a high-class s*x worker. All these shenanigans caught up with him and in 2023, they took away his get-out-of-jail-free card.

Brent S. Wible, the Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General, had this to say about it:

“Farnsworth repeatedly lied to the public... to enrich himself and his co-conspirators.”

---

MoviePass co-conspirator Mitch Lowe’s role

Mitch Lowe, who used to be the boss of MoviePass, has also said he's guilty. He admitted that he wasn't honest with the people who put their money into the company about how long the business could keep going without running into big problems.

Now that Lowe is working with the people trying to figure out if laws were broken, the other guy, Farnsworth, is in deeper trouble because there are more accusations against him. Lowe's lawyers are saying that he really wants to “move forward with his life,” which suggests he's ready to take responsibility for what happened.

The actions of these big-wigs have had a lasting effect on how we trust the guys with the money and how companies are run. They played dirty and it showed everyone there are some holes in the safety net that's supposed to watch over techy businesses. People are now questioning if making a buck with new ideas means you have to be a bit shady.

---

MoviePass' Farnsworth and Lowe still have their day in court waiting.