Who killed Bunny in Only Murders in the Building?

Last Modified Jan 22, 2025 05:10 EST
Who killed Bunny in Only Murders in the Building?
Selena Gomez, Martin Short and Steve Martin (Source: Instagram)


Poppy White, also known as Becky Butler, killed Bunny in Only Murders in the Building.


Only Murders in the Building, created by Steve Martin and John Hoffman, is a mystery comedy-drama that was released on Hulu in 2021. Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez star as three true-crime podcast aficionados who become involved in many murder mysteries during the season. The American television series was renewed for a fifth season in September 2024 and has received critical praise over the course of its four-season run so far. The show has also been nominated for Primetime Emmy Awards and Golden Globes, with all three key actors receiving acting nods.


Warning: The following article contains spoilers for Only Murders in the Building.


Who killed Bunny in Only Murders in the Building?


Who killed Bunny in Only Murders in the Building?
Jayne Houdyshell as Bunny Folger (Source: Only Murders in the Building official Instagram)


In the season finale of season 2 of Only Murders in the Building, Bunny Folger’s murderer is revealed to be Poppy White. White, whose real name is Becky Butler, conspired with her boyfriend Detective Kreps to murder Bunny in order to elevate Poppy’s status and earn her some recognition. Poppy, who worked as Cinda Canning’s assistant, had become frustrated with her lack of success.


She was also frustrated at the fact that she never got any credit for the ideas that Cinda used while she worked with her. Thus, as a result, alongside her boyfriend, Poppy murdered Bunny and created an intricate plot to keep public interest in the case alive while highlighting herself as a key figure in eventually solving it. The show presented several red herrings including Alice and Nina Lin before the main trio eventually uncovered the truth.


What did Bunny say when she died?


Bunny Folger’s last words were initially misheard by the show’s protagonists as they thought she said “14 Savage”. However, as the season progressed and the main characters collected more information, they realized that she said “sandwich” rather than “savage”. Even then, it wasn’t until towards the end of the season that Mabel Mora, one of the protagonists, realized the real truth behind Folger’s last words.


This happened after Mora saw Poppy White order an unusual sandwich combination consistently which took her back to Folger’s last words. It was then Mora figured out that Folger meant “14 Sandwich” referring to the number 14 sandwich at the Pickle Diner, which consisted of liverwurst and marmalade. The number 14 sandwich was the same one that Poppy had ordered the diner on the day that Bunny was murdered.


Also read: What is Only Murders in the Building about?

FAQs on Bunny's killer in Only Murders in the Building

A. In India, Only Murders in the Building streams on Disney+ Hotstar.

A. Yes, Alice did stab Charles albeit accidentally as she intended to stab Mable but hit Charles instead after he shoved her out of the way.

A. As of 2025, there is no news as to when season 5 of Only Murders in the Building is set to be released although it has been confirmed that a fifth season is in development.

Related Stories

1923 Season 2 finale may have just teased another spin-off featuring a different John Dutton 1923 Season 2 finale may have just teased another spin-off featuring a different John Dutton
1923 Season 2 finale may have just teased another spin-off featuring a different John Dutton
2d
The White Lotus Season 3 finale just confirmed a fan theory about Rick, but it led to a tragic fate for Chelsea The White Lotus Season 3 finale just confirmed a fan theory about Rick, but it led to a tragic fate for Chelsea
The White Lotus Season 3 finale just confirmed a fan theory about Rick, but it led to a tragic fate for Chelsea
2d
I firmly believe that HBO's Harry Potter reboot needs to fix some major issues that the original films ignored I firmly believe that HBO's Harry Potter reboot needs to fix some major issues that the original films ignored
I firmly believe that HBO's Harry Potter reboot needs to fix some major issues that the original films ignored 
2d
The Last of Us Season 2 debuts with lower Rotten Tomatoes score that the previous instalment The Last of Us Season 2 debuts with lower Rotten Tomatoes score that the previous instalment
The Last of Us Season 2 debuts with lower Rotten Tomatoes score that the previous instalment
1d
Who played Abby's brother on NCIS? Actor’s career and notable projects, explored Who played Abby's brother on NCIS? Actor’s career and notable projects, explored
Who played Abby's brother on NCIS? Actor’s career and notable projects, explored
2d
The White Lotus Season 3 finale smashed all the viewing records The White Lotus Season 3 finale smashed all the viewing records
The White Lotus Season 3 finale smashed all the viewing records
1d
MobLand review – A blood-soaked symphony of power and betrayal MobLand review – A blood-soaked symphony of power and betrayal
MobLand review – A blood-soaked symphony of power and betrayal
1d
Does Lochlan die in The White Lotus? Here's what we know Does Lochlan die in The White Lotus? Here's what we know
Does Lochlan die in The White Lotus? Here's what we know
2d
What did Sydney Sweeney wear for the Hollywood Beauty Awards 2025? Look decoded What did Sydney Sweeney wear for the Hollywood Beauty Awards 2025? Look decoded
What did Sydney Sweeney wear for the Hollywood Beauty Awards 2025? Look decoded
1d
"Finally buried the hatchet" — Madonna and Elton John settle their differences backstage at Saturday Night Live "Finally buried the hatchet" — Madonna and Elton John settle their differences backstage at Saturday Night Live
"Finally buried the hatchet" — Madonna and Elton John settle their differences backstage at Saturday Night Live  
1d