What did Joel do to Eugene in The Last of Us? Mystery explained

Few stories navigate the messy terrain of morality and survival quite like The Last of Us. From the beginning, it has posed difficult questions with no easy answers, and Season 2 of HBO’s adaptation continues that tradition. One of the most quietly gripping developments this time centers on Eugene, a character who barely registered in the original game but now returns with a haunting presence. His story has been reimagined for television, and the result is more than just a backstory; it’s a slow-burning mystery about what was lost, what had to be done, and the weight of carrying those choices long after the moment has passed. As the truth unravels piece by piece, it becomes clear: this isn’t just about Joel and Eugene; it’s about the shadows that follow even the survivors.

Revisiting the legacy of a world already broken

Originally released as a game that reshaped storytelling in its genre, The Last of Us offered more than a bleak, post-apocalyptic world. It gave us Joel, a smuggler hollowed out by grief, and Ellie, a girl whose existence could change everything. Their journey through a ruined America, devastated by a fungal outbreak, wasn’t just about staying alive. It was about connection, loss, and what people are willing to do when there’s nothing left to lose. HBO’s adaptation, shaped by Craig Mazin and Neil Druckmann, brought that emotional weight to the screen in its first season with startling fidelity. But Season 2 dares to move beyond the source material, taking familiar faces into unfamiliar emotional territory, and in doing so, it finds something quietly devastating.

Who is Eugene, and why did Joel kill him?

One of the most striking departures from the game involves Eugene, played in the show by Joe Pantoliano. In the game, Eugene is a background figure, a former Firefly turned mentor to Tommy, Joel’s brother. He’s remembered fondly, and his death is said to have occurred naturally at the age of 73. In the series, however, Eugene’s fate is not only tragic but also layered in controversy. It’s revealed that Joel killed him, allegedly out of necessity, after Eugene was bitten and began turning into one of the infected. This revelation comes from Gail, Joel’s therapist and Eugene’s widow, who claims Joel “had no choice,” though the bitterness in her voice suggests that the truth may be far more complicated than it seems.

Trauma, therapy, and repressed guilt

Season 2 doesn’t just revisit the past; it lingers there. It leans deeper into flashbacks, memories, and the quiet psychological wear-and-tear that comes with simply staying alive. Recasting Eugene’s death as something Joel did, not just witnessed, adds emotional weight, but it’s the connection to Gail, Joel’s therapist, that truly complicates things. It’s no longer just a plot twist; it becomes a lens into Joel’s unraveling state of mind. The show doesn’t tell us what to think; it lets the ambiguity breathe. And in turning Eugene’s death into something personal, messy, and morally uncertain, The Last of Us expands not only Joel’s inner conflict but also the emotional space the audience is asked to occupy alongside him.

A deliberate narrative shift in adaptation

This creative shift also reflects the showrunners’ broader approach to adaptation. Video games and television operate under different storytelling mechanics: while the game relies on environment and gameplay to develop relationships, the show must externalize conflict in more dramatic ways. Giving Joel a therapist, then placing him in the position of having to kill her husband, creates a tense emotional triangle that allows the writers to explore themes of confession, penance, and estrangement in a way that resonates deeply with a TV audience.

Why dramatizing Eugene’s death matters

This dramatization comes with intention. In the harsh world of The Last of Us, death is a constant, but how people die and how those deaths reverberate matters. By turning Eugene’s passing from a quiet end into an act of violent necessity, the series raises the emotional stakes and brings new tension into its world. It also challenges Joel’s reliability as a narrator of his own story: was Eugene really too far gone, or did Joel act in haste? Does his guilt come from the facts or from a mind that’s long blurred the line between mercy and survival instinct?

Joel’s ever-growing moral ambiguity

This narrative choice also gives the show another opportunity to examine Joel’s ongoing moral ambiguity. From his controversial decision to kill the Fireflies in order to save Ellie to quieter betrayals made in the name of survival, Joel rarely chooses the clean path. Eugene’s death becomes one more entry in a growing ledger of moral debts, one that Gail, and perhaps others, may never forgive.

Grief, justice, and the cost of moving on

Themes of grief and the emotional cost of survival have always been central to The Last of Us, and Eugene’s rewritten fate encapsulates them. Gail’s pain isn’t just about losing her husband; it’s about the lack of justice, the missing context, and the absence of real closure. Her resentment toward Joel isn’t rooted only in the act itself but in the fact that he gets to keep going while others are left behind with the aftermath. It’s a quiet but cutting reflection on how emotional burdens are unevenly carried in a world where everyone is broken, but not everyone is allowed to fall apart.

Audience response and critical praise

Reception to these changes has been largely positive, especially among longtime fans of the franchise. Critics have praised the show’s willingness to expand its world and make bold narrative choices that serve the medium while honoring the emotional essence of the game. Joe Pantoliano’s brief but potent portrayal of Eugene adds emotional weight to a character who was once only a footnote. Meanwhile, Gail’s presence offers something rare, a deeply personal lens on Joel, not as a hero or a partner, but as a patient full of secrets and unresolved pain.

The aftermath of Eugene’s death still lingers

As the season progresses, Eugene’s story seems destined to echo through Joel’s arc, creating space for deeper reflection and emotional reckoning. Whether the full truth ever surfaces remains to be seen, but as is often the case in The Last of Us, what lingers isn’t just the event itself, but the silence that follows.

Edited by Ishita Banerjee

Help Us Improve