"What on earth???????": The Challenge 40 fans react to Rachel being called the female GOAT

The second part of The Challenge 40 Reunion was recently released on January 22, 2025. It featured exciting interactions and discussions between the cast members. Among the participants present at the show's reunion, fans witnessed many vital moments between them.

One of the significant segments on the show's reunion episode was participants voting for female and male Challenge GOAT. Viewers have already witnessed how multiple participants won the show. It included Jenny West, Rachel Robinson, and Jordan Wiseley.

However, during part two of The Challenge 40 Reunion, cast members voted and mentioned the GOAT participants. It was:

• Female Challenge GOAT: Rachel
• Male Challenge GOAT: Jordan.

After seeing Rachel as the female GOAT, it sparked a debate among the show's fans. Because of how Jenny won the season, Rachel was still announced as the GOAT during the reunion's second part.

A fan wrote on social media platform X:

"Why tf is rachel the female GOAT on the challenge at this reunion????? what on earth??????? #thechallenge40 #TheChallenge."

Another fan reacted to Rachel as the female GOAT announcement:

"Please do us a favor and don't invite Rachel back again. She's up there with Laurel on the unbearable scale. I can't stand someone who says they're “for the girls” yet becomes BFFS with a huge misogynist and constantly talks down other women. #thechallenge40."

A netizen commented:

"Was Rachel supposed to let that big conglomerate of an alliance slide through?? Finally someone stood up to that nasty ass alliance! #TheChallenge40."

A user reacted to the female GOAT announcement:

"Rachel the female GOAT? Gtfoh #thechallenge40 #reunion."

A fan mentioned Cara Maria and wrote:

"Damn right she on the mount rushmore. Cara is more of a goat than rachel #thechallenge #thechallenge40."

One more fan mentioned her:

"Rachel the goat. ? Over Cara ?? Foh #thechallenge40."

A netizen reacted:

"#TheChallenge40 Rachel gets a call evry single year, & yet this is the first time Ive seen her on a challenge since battle of the exs. So shes just been saying no to it for the past 13 years."

A person wrote on X:

"Are we actually considering Rachel a winner of this season? That was so undeserved surely? Michele was robbed #TheChallenge40."

---

The Challenge 40 Reunion Part Two: Cast votes for male and female GOAT

The second part of The Challenge 40 Reunion featured a vote among the participants. It was for male and female GOAT - Greatest of All Time participants on the show.

After the participants cast their votes, it was revealed that Rachel was the female GOAT, while Jordan was announced as the male GOAT. Seeing how Rachel turned out to be the GOAT among the female participants sparked a debate among the show's fans.

Fans took to social media platform X and started discussions about the rest of the female cast members who could be GOAT instead of Rachel. Some fans mentioned Cara Maria, while a few fans wrote about Jenny.

A fan also shared how Rachel has been part of the franchise for years and how she has been participating. Some of the fans commented about how Michele was "robbed" of deserving a win and how Rachel was announced as the ultimate GOAT during the reunion.

Apart from fans, The Challenge 40 star Johnny Bananas also criticized the voting and questioned:

"So that's what it's based on, finals?"

Viewers must be aware that the debate about the ultimate GOAT will never end, as everyone has their favorite players from various eras.

---

Fans can stream The Challenge 40 Reunion Part Two on Philo, Hulu, and DirecTV Stream.