For the past decade, Amanda Antoni's family and involved authorities have been in search of answers to her death. This ranges from her ending up on the Body in the Basement episode of Unsolved Mysteries. A vibrant 31-year-old woman from Calgary, Canada, was found in her basement by her husband, Lee, on October 26, 2015. It was a bloody and gory scene with the body of Amanda filled with contusions and a critical head trauma.
The case has, however, been confusing, with officials coming up with several theories to explain the sad circumstances of her death. The spectrum ranges from an accidental fall to the presence of intruders. The possibilities are as chilling as they are confounding. Amanda's family has refused to accept that it was an accident and claims there was foul play.
The episode was released on the 31st of July 2024 as part of Unsolved Mysteries Season 4 on Netflix. Although the case was under investigation, this series did kind of resurrect interest in Amanda Antoni's story, conjuring up a good number of discussions and theories among viewers. Here are the five most convincing, yet disturbing theories surrounding the death of Amanda Antoni.
Amanda Antoni theories that could explain her death as seen on Netflix's Unsolved Mysteries
1) Accidental death
It's a believable theory, with the kind of injuries described and the disarray at the scene. Investigators have initially theorized that she might have fallen down the basement stairs, which perhaps could explain Amanda Antoni's serious head injury and the amount of lost blood.
This theory is further made credible as Amanda could have become disorientated from her migraine. She lost balance on the stairs, or maybe even tripped on her dog. Plus, this theory is very strongly supported by the fact that no signs of breaking in the apartment or struggle were found there and, in addition, all traces of DNA at a crime scene were identified as Amanda's.
For example, the ceramic piggy bank on the stairs might have been bumped into when she fell from the stairs to cause her to bleed. Additionally, discussion threads from Redditors have indicated that she probably tried to get up after falling, which caused the blood to be splattered in the basement. This might be an indication of Amanda Antoni's struggle for help before succumbing to her injuries.
2) Domestic violence
The theory of domestic violence is rather compelling, given the nature of Amanda Antoni's injuries and the dynamics of her marriage. He was ruled out as a suspect, but the evidence surrounding the scene of the crime still raises queries as to whether there was a possibility of foul play.
Amanda's severe bruising and violent scene of first responders suggest a struggle or an attack. This theory is further supported by the fact that family members said they had expressed concerns regarding Lee's temper. They said that, though they thought the relationship was loving, there were those little bits of anger that could be indicative of hidden issues.
Again, the theory is further supported by the context in which Amanda was keeping Lee financially, thus creating an imbalance of power within the relationship. This dynamic of interaction often increases the level of tension and potential for violence, and thus the theory of domestic abuse becomes a worrisome reality.
3) Intruder or break-in
The intruder theory is very convincing, more so considering the couple's neighborhood which was riddled with crime and transient problems. This raises an opportunity wherein someone could have easily bypassed into the home without much hassle.
There were reports from neighbors of unusual noises around that time, about the time of Amanda's last known communication, including the family dog barking, which could indicate that something had disrupted the household.
The overturned chair and the broken phone point to a struggle or a confrontation with the intruder. This opens up some very disturbing questions: how someone could have entered and left without being noticed, given the scene that must have been left behind?
4) Psychological distress
According to the theory of psychological distress, Amanda was perhaps in a mental health crisis which explains her erratic behavior which led to her death. Reports suggest Amanda had migraines that make a person feel dizzy and confused. This might have resulted in her wandering in the basement where she succumbed to her injuries.
This theory is supported by the timing of her decision to stay alone at home as opposed to accompanying her husband on a trip. Amanda's decision to isolate herself, which goes in line with her known health issues, gives a very vivid picture: that of a person who could have easily been overwhelmed by psychological stress.
This theory is credible since it underlines the intricacies of mental health and how it can lead to tragic outcomes when combined with Amanda Antoni's other physical health problems like migraine attacks.
5) Unexplained medical condition
This theory of an undiagnosed medical condition seems quite plausible due to a lack of solid evidence pointing toward foul play. Some theorists said that Amanda Antoni might have had a medical emergency, like a seizure or stroke, which incapacitated her and caused the injuries that ended up killing her.
This theory is supported by the fact that Amanda had no significant internal injuries, usually related to a violent attack, for example, brain trauma or a cracked skull. The chaotic scene could be explained by her trying to find her way around while she was disoriented from the medical episode.
This very possibility raises some important questions about the unpredictability of health conditions and their potential to cause tragic outcomes, especially when one is alone and unable to seek any help.
We will follow the Amanda Antoni story and others with updates as the search for answers presses on.
Keep checking back to Soap Central.
