"TOO Real"— The Challenge fans react to Amanda's reunion appearance

The Challenge finally wrapped up its season 40 with part 2 of the reunion hitting MTV on Jan 22, 2025. After making the fans wait for a whole week, the show finally brought back the entire cast of this season for one last time. Amanda, known for her witty approach and unfiltered expressions, once again captured the attention of the fans when she reacted to Cara Maria and Tori sharing a heartfelt moment.

After hitting a rock several times during this season, Cara and Tori, once best friends, found their friendship to be on a rocky edge with competitiveness taking over. During the reunion of The Challenge, the host offered an opportunity to the ladies to have a discussion and confront each other. What started with the two pointing out how the other one made them feel, the conversation ended with the two expressing their love for each other.

Along with many fans, Amanda felt the entire conversation to be nothing more than a fake act and gave her feelings away with her face, then and there. Fans on social media caught her expressions and filled the internet with their opinions.

A fan posted on X, "Amanda dgaf I’m crying! She’s TOO real!!! #TheChallenge40"

Another person (@TooRealReality_) wrote, "I am hollering at Amanda’s reaction to the Tori and Cara segment. I love her so much 😆😭 #TheChallenge40"

"Me and amanda got the same reaction to this tori cara fake shit #thechallenge #thechallenge40," a post (@madeforreality1) read.

"Cara Maria & Tori are by far the best part of the reunion!!! & the fact that them just laughing so infuriates Laurel & even Amanda is so hilarious!! Like if people just being happy upsets you then you are probably the problem not them. #thechallenge40," a tweet (@MJKolhoff) read.

A netizen (@thom_ahs) commented, "Amanda shaking her head at the Cara & Tori reconciliation LMAOOOO ME TOO GIRL #TheChallenge40"

---

Amanda critiques Cara Maria and Tori's attempt to reconcile their friendship at The Challenge 40 reunion

During the reunion's second half, Amanda delivered sharp looks at Cara Maria and Tori's attempted reconciliation, viewing their connection critically and skeptically. She appeared to perceive their efforts to repair their friendship as fake, implying that their public nature at the reunion was more about producing a spectacle than actually addressing their prior disputes.

Amanda's skeptical look revealed her thoughts on the interaction, showing that she did not believe The Challenge 40's Cara Maria and Tori's efforts to reconcile. Her silent critique underscored the potentially staged quality of their chat, implying that their desire to restore their friendship was more about making a television drama than truly addressing their prior disputes.

---

All the episodes of The Challenge 40 are available on MTV for the fans to binge upon before All Stars 5 hits the small screen on Jan 29, 2025.