Ransom Canyon is being compared to Yellowstone, but they’re missing this one major difference

Netflix's Ransom Canyon has been frequently compared to Yellowstone due to its similar film world and shared themes showcasing ranching families, land disputes, and complex personal relationships.

In the first episode, Staten is grieving over the death of a loved one, meanwhile Quinn is developing some romantic feelings for him. However, Staten is too consumed by his pain to recognise or reciprocate the same. Even by this opening, one can understand how different the new show is from Yellowstone, which showcases Dutton shooting his injured horse in order to free him from his suffering in one of the opening scenes.

The show is significantly different in terms of characters, narratives, and emotional depth. Therefore, comparing it with the popular Yellowstone wouldn't be suitable.

One of the Ransom Canyon actors responded to the comparisons. Here is what he said

The series is set in the Texas Hill Country and follows Staten Kirkland, played by Josh Duhamel, a grieving rancher, and Quinn O’Grady, played by Minka Kelly, a concert pianist returning to her hometown, as they navigate love, loss, and healing. Though portraying a similar world, Ransom Canyon brings out a fresh perspective, offering viewers a more introspective and heartfelt exploration of life in the American West.

According to reports, Zack Schumacher, who plays Yancy Grey, has been responding to comparisons between his show and Yellowstone, two series rooted in the Western drama genre. While he praises Yellowstone and acknowledges its popularity, he emphasises that Ransom Canyon offers something distinct and unique.

“Those Yellowstone shows are incredible—I don’t know anyone who does not like them, myself included, but Ransom Canyon is its world, its own universe. … I think if you’re a fan of Yellowstone, you’re absolutely going to be a fan of Ransom, too—and you’ll enjoy the differences!” He further added, “The female gaze is more present here, which you don’t get in the vast majority of westerns.”

How is Ransom Canyon different from Yellowstone?

Yellowstone often shows grim, brooding men who face off against the world, usually surrounded only by their family or a close-knit inner circle. There’s a sense of isolation and combativeness at the core. There is no hint of light sex, but such scenes are usually rooted in power dynamics and emotional consequences. Yellowstone has not even featured its characters crying as a result of a catharsis, but rather they rant monologues about their realisations. The show also comes with a political overtone, throwing big names like Harrison Ford, Helen Mirren, and Billy Bob Thornton etc.

By contrast, Ransom Canyon appears to be more emotionally generous and intimate, which prioritises pleasure and vulnerability in human connection along with romance and personal growth. As the actor pointed out, it includes female gaze where characters are seen through lenses of tenderness, desire and complexity and not just toughness.

Trending

All 10 episodes of season 1 of the show dropped on April 17 on Netflix. There have been speculations about season 2, but it has not been officially renewed as of now.

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback