"One of the worst people”: Below Deck Down Under fans react to Wihan taking advantage of Alesia

The latest episode of Bravo's Below Deck Down Under has ignited a firestorm of criticism toward bosun Wihan du Toit after an uncomfortable encounter with crew member Alesia Harris.

The April 7 episode featured a scene where an intoxicated Alesia mistakenly climbed into Wihan's bunk, thinking it was Johnny Arvanitis's bed, only for Wihan to allegedly remain silent about the case of mistaken identity. The incident has been compared to the consent issue from the previous season, in which a crew member was fired for entering a person's bed without permission.

Boundary issues have already drawn criticism for Below Deck Down Under, a show that follows yacht crew members as they live and work in close quarters while serving affluent charter clients in Australia. Watchers are debating permission, accountability, and producer involvement in great detail as a result of this most recent controversy.

Social media platforms have erupted with viewers condemning Wihan's behavior, with many calling for his removal from the show and labeling him among the worst crew members in franchise history.

---

Fans react to Below Deck Down Under’s Wihan’s inappropriate behavior with Alesia

The overwhelming majority of Below Deck Down Under viewer responses express disgust at Wihan's actions during the bedroom misunderstanding. Many fans have characterized his behavior as predatory and manipulative, arguing he deliberately took advantage of Alesia's confused state. His decision to remain silent when she mistook him for Johnny has been widely interpreted as a calculated move to create an intimate situation under false pretenses.

“Wihan might be one of the worst people we’ve seen on Below Deck. Not just worst bosun, but worst crew member and a bigger sh–thead than most guests,” a fan commented on X.

More fans chimed in,

“I feel like Wihan took advantage of Alesia! She asked if he was Johnny a few times and instead of getting up and turning on the lights, he lets her get in his bed and he puts his arms around her!” Another fan pointed out.

“Another under the influence unaware girl being taken advantage of by a creep & they way he kept his hand on her back even once she realized and quickly got up to leave…” A fan said.

“He should have got up and turned on the light, not put his arms around her! Who knows how far he would have pushed it, if Johnny didn’t come in!!” One netizen commented.

The fan response has been notably harsh compared to typical reality TV criticism, with viewers of Below Deck Down Under using particularly strong language to condemn Wihan. Many are drawing connections to the show's previous consent scandal, suggesting a troubling pattern within the franchise that production needs to address more forcefully.

“Omfg tonight's episode of Below Deck Down Under...wtf is wrong wirh Wihan?! What a disgusting piece of sh–t,” another user said

“another below deck creep.. get wihan off my tv asap,” a fan said.

“Truly haven’t hated a below deck person more than Wihan…” another netizen commented.

A smaller but vocal minority of viewers has questioned the authenticity of the scene itself. Some speculate about producer involvement or suggest Alesia may have orchestrated the situation to create drama. These viewers point to inconsistencies they perceive in the interaction, including how Alesia could mistake one crew member for another despite physical and vocal differences.

“She was so drunk it didn’t phase her that Johnny was sleeping in the wrong bed, no longer had a Greek accent, and looked exactly like Wihan. Whole thing smelled like producer intervention or Alesia trying to prove some weird point.” A netizen commented.

“She’s too drunk to know what bed she’s getting in? Sounds like a drinking problem. And NO WAY Wihan didn’t know what was happening. Gary 2.0” Another fan commented.

“Harry also brought up at dinner that Wihan would definitely hook up with Alesia if she came on to him. That’s a super weird coincidence. Feels produced or Alesia trying to prove a point.” A fan pointed out.

---

What happened between Below Deck Down Under’s Wihan and Alesia?

The controversial scene occurred after a night of heavy drinking following a charter completion. This episode of Below Deck Down Under showed Alesia visiting Johnny and Wihan's shared cabin, where she climbed into the top bunk belonging to Wihan while apparently believing it was Johnny in the bed.

While Alesia addressed Wihan as if he were Johnny, the bosun reportedly remained silent about the misidentification. The awkward situation only resolved when Johnny himself entered the room, causing Alesia to immediately recognize her mistake and quickly leave the bed.

After the revelation, Alesia attempted to explain the confusion to Johnny, but he appeared unwilling to listen to her explanation. Instead, Johnny returned to the cabin with apparent intentions to quit his position on the yacht on Below Deck Down Under. When Wihan tried to initiate a conversation about the incident, Johnny repeatedly told him to stop talking.

The situation escalated dramatically when Johnny lost his temper, punching the wall as the episode ended with a "To Be Continued" cliffhanger, leaving viewers wondering about the aftermath of the uncomfortable encounter.

This incident arrives at a particularly sensitive time for the franchise, coming just one season after Below Deck Down Under made headlines for firing two crew members over inappropriate behavior. That previous scandal involved a bosun who entered a stewardess's bed while she was unconscious, requiring producer intervention.

The parallel circumstances have prompted viewers to question whether the production team is doing enough to ensure crew member safety and whether they should have intervened earlier in the interaction between Alesia and Wihan.

The controversy also highlights the complex dynamics that emerge when combining alcohol, close living quarters, and the pressure of being filmed. Johnny's violent reaction suggests the incident may have deeper implications for crew relationships and the working environment aboard the yacht.

As the story continues to unfold in upcoming episodes of Below Deck Down Under, viewers will be watching closely to see how Captain Jason Chambers handles the situation, particularly given his statements following last season's scandal about implementing stricter policies to prevent inappropriate behavior.

Whether it was a real misunderstanding, someone pushing boundaries, or just a moment crafted for TV drama, one thing’s clear — it got people talking. And that’s exactly what reality TV is made for: getting viewers hooked and sparking big conversations about the messy, human stuff we see unfold on screen.

---

Below Deck Down Under airs Mondays at 8 p.m. ET/PT on Bravo and is available for streaming the next day on Peacock.