Why was American Gods cancelled after 3 seasons? Here's what we know about the show

American Gods was the ideal blend for a hit series—mythology, intrigue, and a cast of wonderful actors! Then why did the show only run for three seasons? The fans were shocked. What happened? The truth is, American Gods was wracked with a storm of off-camera issues, from changes in creativity to diminishing viewership, that ultimately culminated in its end.

So, why did American Gods get canceled after three seasons? The answer lies in a list of production issues, budget issues, and loss of audiences. With endless showrunner churn, actor exits, and pandemic-related postponements, the show could not maintain its speed. Here's everything that we know about its cancellation and what caused it to shut down before its time.

Creative turmoil on the set of American Gods and showrunner departures

From the beginning, American Gods suffered from creative instability. The first showrunners, Bryan Fuller and Michael Green, who developed the unique visual tone of Season 1, were let go due to disagreements over budget with Starz. Their departure caused a chain reaction of artistic conflicts with new showrunners Jesse Alexander and later Charles H. Eglee.

Each change brought a new vision, disrupting the continuity of the story and infuriating the fans and the cast. Also on the horizon were rumors of tensions between the network and showrunners over the direction of the shows, leading to endless rewrites and reshoots. The endless tit-for-tat not only hindered production but also the quality of the narrative, with audiences kept in suspense and frustrated regarding shift-in plotlines.

Budgetary limitations and delays in production of American Gods

American Gods was a costly production, a premium show with complex special effects, gigantic set pieces, and an enormous ensemble cast. All of these came with a price tag, though. Starz reportedly struggled to make the economics add up as viewership numbers declined. The COVID-19 pandemic also created significant production delays, pushing back schedules and making it even harder to keep the momentum going.

With every passing season, budget cuts were more noticeable. A few of the later episodes were less cinematic in scope than Season 1. A few of the large set pieces and action sequences were cut back or even completely cut out, which led to a noticeable loss of production value.

American Gods cast exits and on-set conflicts

Expand Tweet

The series also experienced cast exits that rocked its foundation. Most notably, Orlando Jones, the fan-favorite Mr. Nancy, was controversially let go before Season 3. His dismissal angered fans, as he attributed off-set drama to his character's dismissal.

Other actors, such as Gillian Anderson and Kristin Chenoweth, also left because of the ongoing creative turbulences. These exits continued to destabilize the show and had an effect on audience interest. Even some of the cast members openly talked about tensions behind the scenes.

Declining viewership of American Gods and varied reaction

Following a tremendous start, American Gods kept on losing viewers over its three seasons. While the first season was widely praised, later seasons performed unevenly due to the issue of pacing and inconsistent storytelling. The loss of core creative minds, changes in the direction of the narrative, and long gaps between seasons made it difficult to retain its audience.

Audiences who were initially interested in the show's mystery and mythology grew tired of the gradual releases. By Season 3, most of the initial buzz had faded, leading to further viewership drops.

The final blow: Starz pulling the plug

After Season 3 wrapped in March 2021, Starz made it official that the show would not be renewed. Rumors of a wrap or revival on another network began to surface but haven't seen the light as of yet. The intricate history of the series left it so unlikely for another network to have it that it really left the fans with an open cliffhanger.

Even since its cancellation, Neil Gaiman, the author of the original book, has had visions of the series being picked back up in some form in the future. There have been no updates officially, though, and American Gods remains in limbo.

American Gods had all the right ingredients, but behind-the-scenes drama soon saw it truncated. With artistic disputes, budget problems, and shrinking viewership, the show could not survive more than three seasons. As much as the fans will never get the conclusion they were given, the legacy of American Gods lives on because of Neil Gaiman's original novel and its devoted fanbase.

For the moment, the series is a compelling case study of how production issues and off-screen strife can sabotage even the strongest adaptations. Whether or not American Gods will return in some guise or another is yet to be determined, but its impact on television cannot be denied.