Who got eliminated from The Challenge All Stars Season 5?

The latest episode of The Challenge All Stars Season 5 witnessed another female pair bid goodbye to the show and $300,000 prize money. Another surprising facet of the elimination arena was Adam and Steve being chosen as the pair to compete in the elimination task for the third consecutive time and coming out of it successfully.

In episode 4, Aneesa Ferreira and Ashley Mitchell competed against Adam and Steve in an elimination challenge called Downpour and lost, unfortunately. Ashley and Aneesa, who were questioned about being chosen as the "Rivals" in Season 5, did not have much bitter history other than getting involved in some online blips now and then.

However, the pair did find acting like a team a little difficult during their time on the show. During the recent episode, Aneesa's joke about Ashley having a "country accent" and being "redneck" creates a seemingly tense situation between the two. However, Aneesa was mature enough to cross the ego bridge and extended an olive branch to Ashley by apologizing.

It was unfortunate, though, that Ashley and Aneesa did not get the time to forge a strong bond as a team and give their fullest to the show. Their journey was cut short, and both the challengers packed their bags after episode 4 of The Challenge All Stars Season 5.

---

How were Ashly Mitchell and Aneesa Ferreira's journeys in The Challenge All Star: Rivals?

The Challenge All Stars: Rivals stars Aneesa and Ashley started not so great this season. The first episode was introductory and involved no elimination, however, in the second episode, the pairs chose self-disqualification, which did not come as a mutual decision.

Following no massive beef, the pair kind of felt stuck during their time in Season 5. struggling to find compatibility and a connection as partners, Asley and Aneesa almost crawled their way till episode 4. Not to forget their latest blip, which involved Aneesa getting a little salty about Ashley's "country accent." During episode 3, Aneesa took a sarcastic dig at Ashley, referring to her as "redneck."

However, while trying to reconcile, Aneesa went to talk to Ashley and admitted that she was wrong to make such a comment, and Ashley was kind enough to let go of the bitterness because she wanted to focus on the challenge as a team. Aneesa, who is coming to The Challenge All Stars after a long hiatus, wished the same and asked Ashey to check her in next time if she oversteps.

Ashley, who had a controversial exit from Season 37, Spies, Lies, and Allies, due to a violation of some unexplained rule,s was happy to make a comeback. However, when she got to know about her rival, Anee,sa she was not that thrilled at first.

During an interview with Entertainment Weekly on January 29, 2025, Ashley remarked that she would have partnered with Hunter, her rival from the previous season. She said:

"God, TJ, where's Hunter when I need him? Oh my God, that would be terrifying, but Hunter is a great competitor. I would love to take the money from him again."

Meanwhile, Aneesa was confident about her social connections in the game and considered having a big group to have her back as an advantage. But it did not help her much in staying away from the elimination danger in the season.

However, the pair managed to have a short and simple journey on The Challenge All Stars Season 5 despite their constant misunderstanding and bickering.

---

The Challenge All Stars: Rivals airs on MTV on Wednesdays at 8 pm ET/PT.