Israel Keyes was worse than the typical horror movie killers—because he was real. He was a methodical serial killer who turned the United States into his personal horror playground for eleven years (2001-2012).
He meticulously planned and executed murders, traveling nationwide and strategically burying deadly tool kits in remote locations months and even years before committing his crimes. Wild Crime explores his enigmatic criminal trail, revealing the brutal impact of a serial killer who defied typical criminal profiles.
Content Warning: Graphic details of violence and violent crimes
The following text addresses murders and methods used by Israel Keyes in graphic detail. If you are sensitive to this type of content, proceed with caution.
Who was Israel Keyes?
Israel Keyes was born in Utah in 1978, in a fundamentalist family. He grew up in an environment marked by isolation, without access to formal schools or friends outside his community. This upbringing shaped an introspective and emotionally disconnected young man—not that it justifies his hideous crimes.
Later, Keyes served in the United States Army, where he learned skills he would use to commit his crimes—discipline, resilience, and, above all, a frightening capacity for planning. Despite his unusual childhood, he was a "social chameleon," able to blend in easily.
He had a daughter, managed a small handyman business, and appeared to be an ordinary man. Behind this calm facade, however, one of the most dangerous and meticulous killers in American history was hiding.
Israel Keyes' Crimes—A macabre game of planning
Keyes did not act on impulse. He operated like a strategist, burying "murder kits"—buckets containing weapons, ammunition, duct tape, gloves, and other instruments—in remote locations, months and even years before using them.
He traveled across the country, choosing random victims, but with a preference for individuals or couples in isolated locations.
His methods were cold and methodical. After kidnapping his victims, he would take them to remote areas where he would carry out the murders. Keyes preferred strangulation, a silent method that left fewer pieces of evidence.
Afterward, he would hide the bodies in hard-to-access locations, ensuring that many of his victims remained missing for years or forever.
Keyes was particularly morbid in Samantha Koenig's case, showing how far he was willing to go to manipulate and control the narrative around his crimes. After strangling her, he froze her body to preserve an appearance of life.
Days later, he thawed the corpse, applied makeup, and sewed her eyes open, taking a grotesque photo that he sent to her family as proof that Samantha was still alive. He used this false image to demand ransom while having already disposed of her body in a frozen lake.
This disturbing staging reflects both his cruelty and his obsession with absolute control, turning others' suffering into part of his sick game.
The skulls and confirmed murders
After his arrest in 2012, Keyes confessed to having killed at least 11 people. In his cell, he left a disturbing note with drawings of 11 skulls, allegedly symbolizing either his victims and/or the years of his killing spree.
Investigators believe the actual number of victims may be even higher, as he refused to reveal all the details before his death.
Among his confessions was the case of Debra Feldman, kidnapped from her home in Hackensack, New Jersey, in 2009. Keyes admitted to killing her and burying her in northern New York, but never revealed the exact location. Samantha Koenig, an 18-year-old cafe attendant in Alaska, was another of his victims.
After kidnapping her, he kept her alive for hours before murdering her. He even froze her body to simulate that she was still alive in ransom photos sent to her family.
Furthermore, Keyes frequently sexually abused his victims before killing them. In his accounts, he detailed how he used kidnapping and deprivation of liberty to exert absolute control, physically and emotionally exploiting his victims. This was the case with Samantha Koenig, who was abused while in his captivity.
This cruel and methodical pattern was part of his power game, showing how he viewed his victims not as people, but as instruments to satisfy his need for domination and manipulation. These brutal details further emphasize the depth of his cruelty and the extent of the suffering he inflicted.
Israel Keyes also mentioned a couple in Vermont, whom he approached at home and killed before burying them in an improvised basement. Many of his crimes remain a mystery, with authorities and families seeking answers that may never come.
How Wild Crime exposes the horror
Wild Crime does more than just present the brutal facts of Keyes' crimes—the docuseries delves into the mind of a serial killer who defied conventions, reconstructing events, using interviews with experts and victims' relatives to give an emotional dimension to the story.
It explores how Keyes manipulated gaps in the justice system, his obsession with control, and his ability to remain invisible for years. At the same time, Wild Crime brings to light the pain and struggle of families, highlighting the lives interrupted by his actions.
Where is Israel Keyes now?
On December 2, 2012, Israel Keyes died by suicide in his cell before his trial for Samantha Koenig's murder. He took his own life by cutting his wrists and using a bed sheet to strangle himself. A blood-written note with disturbing drawings of 11 skulls was found next to his body.
His death put an end to his narrative but left a trail of mystery and unanswered questions. How many victims did Israel Keyes actually make? Where are their bodies? The families of these people still live in limbo, without the chance to find closure.
Trending
Final reflections—Israel Keyes' dark legacy
Israel Keyes was the personification of silent terror, a man who operated in the shadows and manipulated normality to hide his acts, whose crimes left deep marks on the families of his victims and the investigators who faced the weight of his legacy.
Reply
