"Makes no sense": The Challenge All Stars: Rivals fans slam Amber and Faysal for choosing Ashley and Aneesa for the elimination task

The Challenge All Stars: Rivals Season 5 aired its latest episode on February 19, 2025. The fourth episode of the MTV reality show featured Aneesa Ferreira and Ashley Mitchell's elimination.

It happened after they lost the water task against Adam Larson and Steve Meinke. Fans witnessed how Adam and Steve volunteered for the elimination, while Ashley and Aneesa were chosen by Amber Borzota and Faysal Shafaat.

Seeing how Faysal and Amber chose the female participants to compete against the male players, fans slammed them for their choice. Additionally, after witnessing how the task resulted in Ashley and Aneesa's elimination, fans shared their views via social media platform X.

A fan wrote on X:

"Fessy and Amber sending in ashley and aneesa makes no sense #TheChallengeAllStars5."

Another fan called out Amber and Fessy:

"why tf would Amber and Fessy send two girls, Ashley and Aneesa, against two big ass men, Adam and Steve. #TheChallengeAllStars5."

A netizen reacted to Fessy and Amber not going to compete in the elimination task:

"Fessy and Amber could have set themselves up so well if they actually got out their competition and left the layups there for them to beat later… #TheChallengeAllStars5."

A person criticized Amber and Fessy for their choice of players for the elimination task:

"What are Amber & Fessy doing targeting all the weak teams??? #TheChallengeAllStars5."

A netizen reacted on X:

"No more wins for Fessy and Amber weak ass move once again #TheChallengeAllStars5."

Another The Challenge All Stars: Rivals fan blamed Fessy and Amber for Ashley and Aneesa's elimination:

"I can't look this is all Fessy and Amber's fault #TheChallengeAllStars5."

One more fan slammed them for targeting "weak team" for the task:

"How are Fessy & Amber a strong team but a weak team at the same time when it comes down to providing eliminations #TheChallengeAllStars5."

The Challenge All Stars: Rivals fan referred to Amber and Fessy and wrote:

"Again - why the hell are Amber & Fessy sending in FF pairs? What a complete waste of a win. You don't want to send in Devin and Leroy for the repercussions, fine, but at least send someone that can actually beat you #TheChallengeAllStars5."

---

The Challenge All Stars: Rivals Season 5 Episode 4 - Aneesa and Ashley's elimination

The latest episode of The Challenge All Stars: Rivals Season 5 featured a daily challenge followed by an elimination task. The previous episode featured KellyAnne and Sylvia's elimination, after which the remaining participants featured in the fourth episode include:

• Adam Larson and Steve Meinke
• Amber Borzota and Faysal Shafaat
• Aneesa Ferreira and Ashley Mitchell
• Ashley Kelsey and Dario Medrano
• Big T and Corey Lay
• Da'Vonne Rogers and Shane Landrum
• Devin Walker and Leroy Garrett
• Frank Fox and Sam McGinn
• Katie Cooley and Veronica Portillo
• Melissa Reeves and Nicole Zanatta
• Nany Gonzalez and Turbo

As participants gathered during the second half of the episode, the show host, TJ Lavin, asked Adam Larson and Steve Meinke to come forward. For the fans who don't know, the duo volunteered for the elimination task.

Later, when TJ asked Faysal and Aneesa, for the elimination task, whether they would be competing against Adam and Steve or would choose another pair, Faysal responded:

"Tonight TJ it's gonna be Ashley and Aneesa."

He then invited the female participants for the task. Listening to Faysal, Aneesa confessed he was supposed to be her friend.

Witnessing how Faysal and Amber chose the female cast members to compete against the male participants, fans slammed the duo. Some fans slammed Faysal and Amber by mentioning they targeted the "weak teams."

---

Fans can stream The Challenge All Stars: Rivals Season 5 episodes on MTV.