Love Island All Stars Season 2 Episode 31 recap: Elma and Ekin-Su clash during dinner drama

In episode 31 of Love Island All Stars Season 2 which aired on February 12, 2025, tensions escalated between Elma Pazar and Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu during a heated discussion at dinner. Their disagreement stemmed from past events, including the heart rate challenge and a recent game where Elma and Sammy Root questioned Ekin-Su and Curtis Pritchard's relationship.

What began as a disagreement over game decisions led to a confrontation that highlighted ongoing unresolved tensions. The episode ended with neither party fully resolving their differences, leaving the situation between Ekin-Su and Elma unsettled.

---

Tensions rise between Elma and Ekin-Su over past disputes on Love Island All Stars

Disagreement over the "Weakest Couple" question

Elma and Sammy asked the public whether Ekin-Su and Curtis were the "weakest couple" in the Love Island All Stars villa. This did not sit well with Ekin-Su, who expressed her frustration over being singled out. During the argument, Ekin-Su directly addressed Elma, stating,

"I didn't agree with that. I didn't think you needed to ask that...Ever since the heart rate challenge, there's been a weird grudge between you two and us."

Elma questioned Ekin-Su’s reaction, implying that Ekin-Su had initially accepted the discussion by creating the table but later expressed discontent with the situation. The conversation became more heated as Ekin-Su asserted,

"I feel like you have something against me since that heart rate challenge. Let it go."

Sammy attempted to defuse the situation, advising both parties to "just breathe for a sec" and emphasizing that the question was part of the game. However, Ekin-Su stood by her stance, responding,

"I do not agree with your reasons."

---

Argument over past challenges

The argument also touched on previous challenges in the Love Island All Stars villa. Ekin-Su highlighted that she and Curtis had been through challenges together, stating,

"We've been through it. It was real and it was raw, and I felt everything."

She emphasized that their relationship had strengthened despite difficulties. Elma countered by expressing skepticism about Ekin-Su's reactions, saying,

"Things on your side get messy, and then you blame others for it."

Sammy emphasized that the question was a necessary part of the game, pointing out that players are required to make choices in such situations. The disagreement also involved the dynamics between the couples. Sammy asked Ekin-Su,

"If Elma kissed Curtis, you wouldn’t be like that."

In response, Ekin-Su emphasized that the situation should not be taken personally, explaining that the challenges were part of the game. The conversation continued with both sides defending their positions regarding the challenges and the decisions made during them.

---

Confrontation over language and apologies

As the discussion progressed, Ekin-Su took issue with how Elma spoke to Curtis, specifically referring to a previous moment when Elma told Curtis to "shut up and f**k off." Ekin-Su firmly stated,

"No one talks to my man like that. It’s wrong."

Elma later walked away from the conversation but discussed it with the other girls inside the Love Island All Stars villa. She stated,

"Telling me to get over something because it's just a game—well, you get over it now, babe, because it’s just a game."

When Elma returned to the conversation, Ekin-Su emphasized that Elma should apologize to Curtis for her previous remarks. However, Elma disagreed and instead suggested that Ekin-Su should apologize to her for how she had spoken during their argument. As tensions remained high, Curtis noted that Elma had not yet apologized, stating,

"She actually didn’t apologize, to be fair."

Sammy acknowledged that Elma admitted she should not have said certain things, but Curtis maintained that the apology should be made directly.

---

Fans can expect more intense confrontations, shifting alliances, and surprising twists as Love Island All Stars continues. With tensions running high and relationships being tested, upcoming episodes are likely to bring even more drama and unexpected moments in the villa.

Catch all the latest drama on Love Island All Stars, airing every night at 9 PM on ITV2, except on Saturdays.