“Kelly clarkson-level talent” — American Idol fans react to Drew’s audition performance 

The American Idol Season 23 auditions resumed with a display of many talents from the country in episode 4, which aired on March 23, 2025. Lionel Richie, Luke Bryan, and Carrie Underwood, the judges, were treated to a series of performances that demonstrated the diversity and depth of this season's competitors. One of the most memorable auditions was that of 26-year-old Drew Ryn, whose performance made a lasting impression on the crowd and judges alike.

Drew, who currently resides in Nashville after relocating from Arizona, brought a wealth of musical experience to the stage. During her audition for American Idol, Drew decided to sing an original song, "Walk on Water." Because of her heartfelt performance and the moving lyrics, judges Luke Bryan and Carrie Underwood appreciated her performance with heartfelt compliments.

Fans shared their admiration for Drew's audition on social media, echoing the judges' opinions. Social media was flooded with admiration, with many people comparing Drew to Kelly Clarkson, the first-ever American Idol winner. An admirer of the American Idol posted on X:

"Drew was absolutely incredible. that's a kelly clarkson-level talent right there. #americanidol"

Another fan shared from his account:

"Drew doesn’t need permission to go to Hollywood, she’s been training for this moment since her #AmericanIdol karaoke machine days!"

An X user wrote:

"Where has Drew been hiding??? What a voice 🔥 she’s going to be a star #AmericanIdol"

"Wow, Drew ryn's original song is amazing, And she sounded incredible during the auditions this week #AmericanIdol," another tweet read.

Another X user posted:

"Drew ryn is going to hollywood #AmericanIdol."

Many fans even remembered Drew's performance from her time in The X Factor.

A netizen posted:

"Omg time flies by fast. I remember when Drew was on the X Factor in the United States. Her audition was incredible tonight. Loved it! #Idol #AmericanIdol"

"I remember Drew from #TheXFactor (USA) . She followed me on here but I think her account is gone now. #AmericanIdol #idol," read an X user's comment.

---

"Very believable" — American Idol Season 23 judge Carrie Underwood praises Drew's performance

During Season 23 of American Idol, Drew Ryn gave a passionate performance of her original song, "Walk on Water." The judges were enthralled and impressed by her strong vocals and depth of feeling. The vocalist stood out in a crowded lineup because of her ability to connect with her songs and display her skills:

"You're very believable...It was a gamble that paid off," Carrie Underwood said recognizing Drew's sincerity.

Viewers responded favorably to the comment, complimenting the singer's stage presence and vulnerability. Drew's performance was one of the night's most impressive auditions, not only secured her a golden ticket to Hollywood but also stoked excitement for her future.

---

Watch more performances of American Idol Season 23 on ABC.