"It's just too serious" When Jeremiah Robision's Beloved Shirts left Shark Tank empty handed

Standing amid pizza-themed bedding and unicorn merchandise on Shark Tank, Jeremiah Robison faced the panel with a bold declaration:

"The problem with the world today is that it's just too serious."

His company, Beloved Shirts, aimed to inject some much-needed fun into fashion with quirky, custom-printed designs. Despite $2.3 million in sales over two years and a celebrity boost from Katy Perry sporting their pepperoni pizza onesie, Robison walked away from Shark Tank without a deal.

The 2016 episode showcased the unique charm of Beloved Shirts—and the business challenges that made the Sharks hesitate. Robison came seeking $175,000 for 5% equity, armed with custom shirts bearing the Sharks' faces and a pre-made "You've got a deal!" pepperoni t-shirt that, ironically, never got its moment to shine.

What happened during Jeremiah Robision’s Shark Tank pitch?

The roots of Beloved Shirts trace back to 2012, when Robison was tasked with designing jerseys for his indoor soccer team.

"That idea led me to explore this idea of printing they call sublimation," he told ABC 4.

Elaborating:

"Instead of doing it on jerseys, I did actual fashions."

The brand hit its stride when Katy Perry wore their pepperoni pizza onesie to the Philadelphia Museum of Art in 2014. "That took us to the next level," Robison noted. But viral moments don't guarantee business success.

The numbers seemed solid - over 22,000 products on offer and millions in sales. But the made-to-order business model raised red flags. Long turnaround times and inventory management challenges made the Sharks nervous.

Shark Tank's Mark Cuban worried about the company's staying power beyond initial hype. While Daymond John showed interest with an offer of $175,000 for 25%, negotiations stalled when Robison's counter of 15% couldn't bridge the gap to John's final offer of 22.5%.

How did Beloved Shirts fare after Shark Tank?

Despite leaving empty-handed, Robison remained positive. "It was an incredible experience," he told Yahoo Finance.

"To be in the same room with these great business minds and feed off of that energy was huge. Pitching my business to them was such a rush."

The Shark Tank effect wasn't quite what he expected. "The biggest mistake I made was overestimating the impact," Robison revealed on The Jimmy Rex Show.

"I actually invested in about $80k worth of hoodies for when the episode aired and we're still selling some of them."

Beloved Shirts proved the Sharks wrong by steadily growing. Sales hit $1 million in 2019, $2 million in 2020, and $3 million in 2021. Their Instagram following swelled to nearly 100,000, with celebrities like Eric Andre sporting their designs.

The product line expanded beyond clothing to include pandemic masks, phone holders, door mats, and shower curtains. Their signature style even spawned an "Air Con" Nicholas Cage throw pillow.

However, success brought growing pains. The Better Business Bureau's F rating reflects ongoing delivery and product issues—though made-to-order businesses often face similar challenges with customer expectations.

For Robison, who calls himself a "serial entrepreneur," Beloved Shirts was just the beginning. He's since launched Flexliving, an affordable athleisure brand, and Golden Pickleball, targeting America's fastest-growing sport.

"I'm really confident we are going to take this to the next level and be a globally recognized brand."

He told ABC 4 in 2016.

---

Sometimes leaving the Shark Tank empty-handed isn't the end of the story—it's just the beginning of a different kind of success.