"It's not a big deal": Love Island All Stars' Harriett tries to reconcile after feud with Casey

Harriett and Casey, one of the Love Island All Stars islanders, addressed their ongoing conflict after a game in the latest episode, which aired on February 10, 2025, with Harriett stating,

"Like you know I didn't mean it like that like I, I was just saying it but it's not a big deal."

The conversation, facilitated by fellow islander Ronnie, involved Casey expressing his dissatisfaction with Harriett’s initial apology. While both parties engaged in dialogue, the resolution remained uncertain, as other islanders commented on the sincerity of the exchange.

---

Casey questions Harriett’s apology as Love Island All Stars villa reacts to their dispute

Ronnie acts as a mediator

Ronnie played a central role in facilitating communication between Harriett and Casey. Initially, Harriett expressed disinterest in escalating the situation, stating,

"Yeah I'm fine I just like I just boring Ronnie."

Ronnie offered to intervene, asking,

"Do you want me to say something to him?"

Harriett instantly responded with a "no." However, Ronnie later took the initiative and encouraged Casey to address the matter directly with Harriett.

When Casey approached Harriett, she questioned the way he was moving toward the conversation and told him to be more composed. Casey clarified that he had been called over and responded,

"I just got told to come over here come here."

Harriett then emphasized her perspective, saying,

"Like it's really weird like you could have just come."

---

Disagreement over the apology

During their conversation, Casey explained that he felt Harriett’s apology lacked sincerity. He stated,

"Okay I came over and I just I just I just wanted an apology and I just feel like it wasn't sincere at all."

Harriett defended her initial statement, responding,

"I'm sorry that I spoke to you like that I just felt like you were coming at me right and I am sorry for saying that but I honestly didn't mean it like that."

Casey further elaborated on his feelings, saying,

"I just feel like in that moment because it was quite heated it wasn't bannering at that specific time maybe just that's why and that's why I felt pretty offended."

He provided an example to illustrate his perspective, stating,

"Like Imagine if I told you to shut the f**k up like you'd be fuming at me."

Ronnie agreed with Casey’s point, indicating that he understood why Casey felt that way.

---

Love Island All Stars villa reactions and uncertainty

Other Love Island All Stars islanders expressed skepticism regarding the resolution of the conflict. Before Casey and Harriett spoke directly, Gabby shared her thoughts on Harriett’s apology, suggesting that it lacked sincerity and advising Casey on how to handle the situation. She said to Casey,

"She apologized but it wasn't like she didn't it didn't come from the heart yeah yeah well I think if you speak to her again you just need to be just really calm."

Luca on the other hand remarked,

"I don't think you're done what I don't think you're done...no she's basically got Ronnie back up now."

Their exchange indicated that some islanders believed tensions between Harriett and Casey remained unresolved. As the conversation between Casey and Harriett concluded, Ronnie encouraged a positive resolution, saying,

"But we're all good brother."

Casey and Ronnie then exchanged words of camaraderie, with Ronnie expressing affection and Casey reciprocating the sentiment.

---

While Harriett and Casey acknowledged their differences, the reactions from other islanders suggest that tensions in the Love Island All Stars villa may not be fully resolved.

Tune in for the latest episodes of Love Island All Stars every day (except Saturdays) at 9 PM UTC on ITV2.