"Does not make sense": Love Island: All Stars fans demand the show makers post "votes" after the winner announcement

The latest Love Island: All Stars Season 2 episode - finale revealed Casey and Gabby as the winners. After the news was spread, some of the fans didn't take it well and demanded proof of the public voting from the show makers.

While sharing their sides of who should have won, some fans recalled Casey's behavior with Catherine from the show's 30th episode. Others mentioned the rest of the five finalists, who should have won the reality show.

Love Island: All Stars Season 2 Finale aired on February 17, 2025, where the host announced the winning pair, Casey and Gabby. Seeing how their favorite couples didn't win the show, some of the fans demanded to see the proof of votes. Viewers must know that the winners were chosen based on the public voting.

A fan wrote on X:

"Can love island post the votes because logically it does not make sense. if it was not luca and grace i'm surprised it was not ekin and curtis. the only two couples we saw online #loveisland."

Another fan mentioned:

"I will never forgive y'all for putting the potential winner couple Ekin and Curtis in third place while Luca and grace in 2nd place I'm terribly pissed #LoveIslandAllStars #LoveIsland."

A netizen reacted to the voting for the show's finale:

"The fact that Gabby & Casey won over Ekin & Curtis and Grace & Luca is f*cking insane. Who the f*ck voted for them???? #LoveIsland."

A fan commented about Ekin-Su and Curtis:

"Omg noooo I thought Ekin and Curtis would win #LoveIsland."

Another fan reacted to Ekin-Su not winning the Love Island: All Stars Season 2:

"Ekin Su - my shaylaaa. You will always be famous #LoveIslandAllStars #loveisland."

A person wrote about Ekin-Su:

"YALL better treat ekin with SOOO MUCH LOVE once she comes out of that villa. She SAVED the season with her drama #LoveIslandAllStars #loveisland."

A netizen commented about Casey and Gabby's win:

"tbh idk why y'all didn't see casey and gabby winning this. i just knew it was between them, luca and grace, ekin and curtis. the fb moms are backing them all throughout and most of the islanders wanting them to because they've been with casey in this show before. #loveisland."

Another person reacted to Curtis and Ekin-Su coming in third:

"#loveisland I tell you why it's actually better that Ekin/Curtis came in 3rd. She surpassed that bully Grandma Elma and she got to see arrogant Luca who just knew he'd win come in 2nd place AGAIN!"

---

Love Island: All Stars Season 2: Winner revealed - Casey and Gabby

Love Island: All Stars Season 2 Finale was released on February 17, 2024. Finalist five couples featured on the episode were:

1. Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu and Curtis Pritchard,
2. Gabby Allen and Casey O’Gorman,
3. Catherine Agbaje and Omar Nyame,
4. Elma Pazar and Sammy Root,
5. Grace Jackson and Luca Bish.

Later on, the top two couples were revealed: Luca - Grace and Casey - Gabby. When the show host, Maya, asked the finalists to share how their journey on the All Stars' second season had been so far, Casey stated:

"I absolutely adore her, like, she's just blown me off my socks since I've come in here. Is that a saying? I don't even know. But I just haven't found my connection before in here, and as soon as that first conversation I had with her, it was just game over for me."

Listening to his feelings, Love Island: All Stars' Gabby also reciprocated the emotions and said she was "grateful."

Later on, when the duo, Casey and Gabby, were revealed as the winners, it created quite a stir among the show's fans. Some also demanded the "proof" of voting and commented that the show makers need to "post" the voting proof.

---

To witness everything that happened on Love Island: All Stars Season 2 Finale, fans can stream the episode on ITVX.