When Dateline: Secrets Uncovered revisited the case of Susan Winters' suspicious death, what seemed to be a lethal suicide all too readily fell apart as something much more complicated. Her husband, Gregory "Brent" Dennis—a licensed Henderson, Nevada, psychologist working out of an office in town—was at the center of the inquiry.
Dennis was well-regarded by Las Vegas' mental health community. They appeared to have a healthy home life. But the case went in a different direction when new evidence countered initial speculation.
Susan Winters died on January 3, 2015. Her death was initially suspected as a suicide from antifreeze (ethylene glycol) and oxycodone in her body. But inconsistencies within the case and suspicions on the part of Susan's parents led to further investigation. A private investigator was recruited, and the case was reopened in 2016.
What was Brent Dennis's role within the case shown in Dateline: Secrets Uncovered ?
Brent Dennis was married to Susan Winters. The police suspected him initially when he had told them Susan was depressed, but the story would subsequently change once the authorities found out about money motives. Dennis collected huge amounts from Susan's accounts upon her death, around $2 million in life insurance policies.
Dennis was indicted for murder in 2017 and was arrested. He pleaded to voluntary manslaughter on an Alford plea in 2022, which is when a defendant will not plead guilty but will admit there was sufficient evidence to convict. He was sentenced to three to ten years of prison time.
Who was Susan Winters, and what was her fate?
Susan Winters was a well-known lawyer and judge who worked part-time in Henderson, Nevada. She was well-rooted in the community of lawyers and was known to be extremely hardworking regarding work and family. Her unexpected death surprised all those who knew her.
Early on, she was eager to be labeled as a suicide case, but her case was subsequently reopened due to insistent pressure from her parents, who were sure that their daughter would never commit suicide. Toxicology tests showed fatal concentrations of ethylene glycol and oxycodone, medications usually employed in suicide or deliberate poisoning.
But with erratic financial records and a history of drug dependence on Dennis' record, the initial ruling was then amended to "undetermined," leaving the case open to court trials.
Financial motive and red flags
Dateline discovers that as the investigation continued, the accounts began to reflect a troubling trend. Brent Dennis would have been left with more than $2 million in life insurance after Susan had died. Furthermore, he withdrew around $200,000 from her accounts shortly after her death.
Prosecutors subsequently disclosed Dennis was a substance user and had a history of ongoing financial troubles—something Susan was reportedly well aware of. Prosecutors stated they had reason to believe she was headed to confront or report him, which they speculate could have been a motive. These findings altered the case from probable suicide to one of more complex circumstances with desperation for money and potential intent.
The legal case: From suicide to manslaughter
The death of Susan had originally been reported as a suicide, but upon investigating the latest case, the cause was revised to "undetermined." Brent Dennis had been arrested and charged with murder back in February of 2017.
In 2022, however, the court's legal decision reached a turning point. Dennis pled guilty to a conviction of voluntary manslaughter on an Alford plea, which kept him from being able to assert any guilt regarding acceptance of the conviction. His judge sentenced him to three or ten years in prison.
The plea bargain saved time and money but left things in the air regarding intent, scheming, and justice. The Susan family, while still grieving, could finally breathe a sigh of relief at the case finally ending in some degree of accountability.
According to KTNV Las Vegas, Dennis' lawyer read statements on behalf of both of his two daughters,
"The signs of suicide are not always black and white, and our mother is a perfect example of someone who had a seemingly perfect life with little to no reason to commit suicide. Losing our mother was the hardest day of our lives, but the accusations against our father have brought trauma that cannot be overstated."
What did Dateline reveal in "Secrets Uncovered"?
The Dateline: Secrets Uncovered TV show about this case provides an insight into how a sudden death with little physical evidence can become a multi-year court battle. The show includes interviews with Susan's parents, police officers, legal experts, and other individuals who were part of the case.
It follows the timeline of the events, from the death of Susan and the initial suicide verdict to the monetary investigations and final plea bargain. Significantly, the episode points out how circumstantial and monetary evidence, in place of direct forensic proof, had a central role to play in building the prosecution's case.
Dateline does not dramatize what occurred, instead giving us a chronological breakdown of the decisions and evidence leading to the conviction. It demonstrates the dedication of Susan's parents and the challenges of coping with death investigations of family members and drug-related causes.
Gregory "Brent" Dennis was finally convicted of voluntary manslaughter of his wife, Susan Winters, by means of an Alford plea. Although he didn't confess to anything, he admitted that the evidence presented by the prosecution would most likely result in a conviction. Dateline: Secrets Uncovered explores this surprising and complex case by explaining how financial investigation, family advocacy, and medical forensics led to the truth.