Dateline: Bringing Brooke Home — What happened to Brooke Wilberger? Details of the 19-year-old's disappearance explored

Brooke Wilberger’s disappearance on May 24, 2004, shook the small, peaceful community of Corvallis, nestled in the heart of Oregon. She was 19, a college student savoring her summer break from Brigham Young University. Her sister managed the Oak Park Apartments where Brooke worked part-time.

On the fateful day, Brooke Wilberger was last spotted with a pail of water in hand. She had been tasked with cleaning the lamp posts. The Dateline episode, titled Bringing Brooke Home, shows how the investigation took a turn when it intersected with another troubling incident that had happened in New Mexico. It led to Joel Courtney, a man prone to violence. DNA evidence pointed to him.

In 2009, Courtney admitted his guilt and confessed to taking Brooke’s life. In a deal that allowed him to serve his sentence in New Mexico, he disclosed the location where he had concealed her body. This brought a painful conclusion to a case that had haunted the community for so long.

---

Brooke Wilberger’s life and the day she vanished

Born on a February morning in 1985, in the heart of Fresno, California, Brooke Wilberger grew up in a tight-knit, religious family in Oregon. She was the fifth of six siblings, and was nurtured in a warm Mormon environment that instilled strong values. Brooke was a young woman adored for her sharp intellect, physical prowess, and heart.

At Elmira High School, Brooke Wilberger became a beacon of talent, shining in sports like basketball, soccer, and track. Her family and friends knew her as someone with a smile and an unbreakable spirit.

The year 2004 brought the promise of joyful anticipation for Brooke Wilberger. She had her sights set on reuniting with her childhood sweetheart, Justin Blake, who was fulfilling his Mormon mission in Venezuela. However, tragedy struck in the months leading up to their reunion.

She disappeared on May 24, 20004. The day began as any other, with Brooke busy outside the Oak Park Apartments. Her sister Stephanie saw her around 10 a.m. but Brooke wasn't around when lunch hour arrived. Stephanie then felt a sense of unease.

What Stephanie discovered next was terrifying: Brooke Wilberger's flip-flops lay broken, next to her abandoned bucket. The silence all around seemed ominous and, as the moments ticked away, the gravity of the situation grew heavier.

A distraught Stephanie called for help, setting in motion a frenzied search. The local authorities received the distressing call at 3:07 p.m., and the race to find Brooke Wilberger was on. Whispers of a scream had reportedly been heard around 10:30 a.m., yet no one had witnessed the source of the sound.

Hope mixed with fear as the search for Brooke grew into a community effort, with prayers being offered.

---

How did investigators catch Joel Courtney?

Despite an exhaustive search that included scrutinizing local people with questionable pasts, especially s*x offenders, Brooke Wilberger's disappearance remained shrouded in mystery for a considerable period.

In 2005, a significant revelation unfolded in Albuquerque, New Mexico. A young woman from overseas, who was a student in the area, had been kidnapped, and she managed to escape from her captor, Joel Courtney. Witnesses described Courtney's vehicle, which eventually led to his apprehension on charges of s*xual assault and kidnapping.

As authorities dug into Courtney's background, it emerged that he had a history of sexual aggression. His ex-wife had gone so far as to seek legal protection in the form of a restraining order, highlighting his dangerous nature. During this investigation, an unexpected connection surfaced between Courtney and Brooke's case. His DNA was found in a work van he had been using in Oregon, which provided irrefutable evidence linking him to her disappearance.

Under intense questioning, Courtney ultimately admitted to the crimes he had committed against Brooke Wilberger. He confessed to kidnapping her, inflicting terrible violence, and, tragically, taking her life before discarding her body. In a courtroom in 2009, Courtney decided to plead guilty. His plea prevented a death sentence.

As part of the deal, he revealed the whereabouts of Brooke's remains. Her family was finally saw a tragic closure to the case, by bringing her body home for burial, after confirming her identity through a watch she had been wearing. It was a gift from Brooke's mother on Christmas.

---

Brooke Wilberger's story is a part of Dateline: Secrets Uncovered series, which is on Peacock and the Oxygen app.

More Dateline cases: Matt Podolak | Thomas Foley's wife, Dar Foley