Dateline: A Villainous Plan – Who was Matt Yussman and what happened to him? Disturbing details of the 2015 incident, explored

Dateline: A Villainous Plan covered the case of Matt Yussman, an executive at a credit union in Bristol, Connecticut, who was the target of a frightening crime in February 2015. He and his mother were brutally kidnapped by two career criminals, Michael Benanti and Brian Witham, in a chilling scheme aimed at extorting money from Yussman's credit union.

The robbers, who had meticulously targeted Yussman by his public persona, coerced him into robbing his own office under threat of killing him and his mother using phony bombs. The offense was part of a bigger, multi-state crime wave that involved similar offenses in Tennessee and North Carolina. But what did Yussman experience, and how did he make it through this terrifying ordeal?

The Dateline series "A Villainous Plan" goes in-depth on the frightening specifics of the kidnapping and ransom scheme that put Yussman and his mother into a battle for survival. What began as an apparent robbery turned out to be a sophisticated, meticulously planned crime scheme. The criminal partners' motive wasn't personal—it was monetary. And for Yussman, the next thing was an awful experience that would leave a permanent scar on his life.

Here's the official trailer for your reference:

Facts of the offense in Dateline: A premeditated plan

As shown in Dateline, Matt Yussman and his mother were abducted from their house on the morning of February 2015 by Benanti and Witham. The offenders, who had committed similar offenses in other states before, had targeted Yussman using information available to the public. After gaining entry into the house, they made Yussman wear a mock bomb, which they said was linked to a lethal device. They also bound a device similar to the first to his mother, utilizing these threats to make them cooperate with the demands of the criminals.

Benanti and Witham's aim was simple: extorting money from Yussman's credit union. Yussman was ordered to attempt to withdraw $1 million from the credit union and hand it over to the perpetrators. They ordered him to report to the bank, collect money, and pay it over to them. Yussman and his mother were continuously threatened with violence during the experience. The perpetrators were not acquaintances of Yussman, and they had a strictly financial motive. Their actions were deliberate, taking advantage of Yussman's access to the financial institution and his status as a target for an extortion racket.

The perpetrators' role in Dateline

Michael Benanti and Brian Witham were both experienced criminals who had committed similar offenses in other states, such as Tennessee and North Carolina. Their motivation in this instance was economic—Yussman was not personally familiar to them, and they were not acting out of any personal hostility. Rather, they targeted him because of his occupation at the credit union. The perpetrators employed their familiarity with his professional position to manipulate him into trying the robbery, using threats of violence to compel his cooperation.

Both Witham and Benanti had criminal backgrounds and were experienced with executing complicated crimes. They thoughtfully planned the robbery and kidnapping, making certain they had a victim who was placed in a position to provide them access to significant amounts of money.

The investigation and legal outcome

As depicted in Dateline, after the crime was committed, Matt Yussman was initially viewed as a person of interest within the investigation. The investigators aimed to learn more about his level of involvement because the nature of the crime itself was intricate and unconventional. Nonetheless, as there was increasing evidence, it transpired that Yussman himself was a victim of the crime and had been coerced into assisting by coercion.

The culprits, Michael Benanti and Brian Witham, were later caught and charged with several crimes, among them kidnapping, robbery, and extortion. Benanti was handed multiple life terms (plus 155 years), while Witham was handed a 42-year term for his involvement in the scheme. The legal verdicts brought about a feeling of closure, yet the psychological and emotional impact on Yussman and his mother persisted. The offense itself underscored the weaknesses of those who hold positions of authority, as well as the extent to which criminals may go to take advantage of those who hold such positions for monetary purposes.

Matt Yussman's kidnapping and extortion story on Dateline is a reminder of the dangers that can come from holding a position of authority, especially one that provides access to monetary resources. The crime, though one isolated incident, was one part of a larger crime wave that struck other financial institutions and workers. The perpetrators of the scheme were professional and deliberate, with no personal vendetta against Yussman, but rather a definite intention of making money through extortion.

As reported in Dateline: A Villainous Plan, the case illustrates the alarming tendency for criminals to use vulnerable people to achieve their financial ends. For Yussman, the experience had permanent emotional effects, but it also highlighted the detailed nature of the crime and the need for a comprehensive investigation to bring the criminals to justice. Although the criminals were sentenced and convicted, the trauma felt by Yussman and his family will forever be part of their lives.

Trending

Also read: Dateline: The Widow Of Woodland Hills - Everything we know about the latest true crime episode

Dateline: The Last Mile - Everything we know about the latest true crime episode

×

Was this article helpful?

Thank You for feedback