“Crazy work” — The Challenge 40 fans react to Michelle calling CT an overrated player

The first part of The Challenge 40 reunion went live on MTV on January 15, 2025, and it spent no time getting into the season's most dramatic moments. The reunion, hosted by Maria Menounos, provided an opportunity to talk about unresolved conflicts and unexpected opinions. From unresolved rivalry to tearful apologies, the cast didn't hold back. However, one of the most talked-about moments occurred when Michelle Fitzgerald made a questionable comment regarding CT, sparking strong reactions both on set and online.

Michelle criticized The Challenge legend CT Tamburello, calling him an "overrated" player. Her remark shocked viewers and cast members, as many of them see CT as one of the best competitors in the show's history. Michelle argued that CT's success was mostly due to good circumstances rather than his own competence, calling into question his highly celebrated reputation. The cast instantly got into the debate.

---

The Challenge 40 fans react to Michelle calling CT an overrated player

As the cast of The Challenge 40 got together for the reunion, Michelle commented on CT's performance during the season. Fans flooded social media to share their feelings, with many calling out Michelle for her statement, disregarding her criticism of CT, a player who has continuously proven himself across various seasons and formats.

A fan posted on X, "Michelle are you okay ?? Calling CT overrated is crazy work! #TheChallenge40"

"If Michelle is saying CT is overrated I don’t know about that but WHO DO WE THINK IS overrated player of all time & no it not @johnnybananas #TheChallenge40," another user wrote.

"Michelle said CT is overrated. Girl bye. #thechallenge #thechallenge40," a person posted.

An admirer mentioned, "#thechallenge40 @ChrisTamburello michelle called you overated. You need a ct revenge tour hun!!!"

A few viewers of The Challenge also called Michelle out for not being happy about getting the third position.

"michelle is acting like she didn't win money 🙄, Tori and kyland got nothing and they're still celebrating with everyone but she wants to be boo whoing cuz she got 3rd 🤭.#TheChallenge40 #ungrateful," an X user posted.

Another netizen wrote, "Ugh. Michelle and her sad puppy dog faces in this reunion makes me want to throw a branch at her. I can't stand her sore loser bullshit #TheChallenge40"

Another post from an X account read, "Michelle really called CT overrated? 😖 #thechallenge40"

Many even questioned if the tie makes Michelle's position 2nd or 3rd.

A fan questioned, "If Rachel and Jenny were both first how was Michelle not 2nd n Tori 3rd??? #TheChallenge40"

"Michelle getting 3rd place when there was a tie with 1st?? Doesn’t that make her 2nd place? #challenge40 #TheChallenge40."

Another fan posted on his X account.

---

MTV released part 1 of The Challenge 40 reunion on Jan 15. The second part of this two-day get-together will go live Jan 22, 2025.