Black Mirror's “Plaything” review : A study of loneliness, legacy, and the monsters we build

Episode four of Black Mirror’s Season 7 finds beauty in madness and memory—a haunting descent brought to life by Peter Capaldi’s wickedly mesmerizing performance.

Within the multitude of nightmares encapsulated by Black Mirror—the black hole that serves as a flaring void of our collective creativity – the juxtaposition of our technology, boundaries of empathy, and identity's fragile scaffolding come alive as terrifying specters.

Season 7's Plaything does not reflect surreptitiously; instead, “haunting” serves as a more suitable term, reflecting dread in every inch of the directing, surgical precision writing.

Starting with the fictional near-future 2034, weaving in mid-late 90s rife with trauma narratives, the episodes unfold in the life of Cameron Walker, whose frayed childhood, more digitized nightmares, is worse than a singular crime tale.

Perhaps the most devastating experience the series has ever delivered, it smothers the audience and takes them on a journey through psychological horror, revealing itself as a slowly unraveling part detective procedural.

---

The fragile mind of Cameron Walker

One of the most quietly haunting depictions of Peter Capaldi’s career comes in the shape of Cameron, a man teetering at the edge of psychological existence. He appears utterly spent, emotionally void, drifting helplessly after something he cannot even vaguely articulate.

The initial scene is set during the mundane act of stealing a cheap bottle of spirits, an action that is markedly superficial but still somehow representative of a much deeper chronic life affliction.

As the two detectives, DCI Kano and Jen Minter, begin the unravelling, in their attempt to comprehend Cameron’s life, his history, his past sets forth like a brutal display of violence, grinding abuse, merciless bullying, and debilitating loneliness.

The younger Cameron is quite beautifully captured by Lewis Gribben, a portrayal that oscillates between tender and haunting, capturing the character’s vulnerability. Cameron finds solace in the world of computer games and, far more importantly, Colin Ritman, a famed game developer whose moniker is well known to Black Mirror aficionados due to his role in Bandersnatch.

As time progresses, all those fond memories morph into obsessions, and memories transform into something different entirely, perhaps a lost computer file waiting to be accessed.

---

Reality as simulation, simulation as confession

At its core, “Plaything” navigates the relationships intertwined between technology and mental trauma while portraying how personal regret can manifest and become autonomous through code. In Cameron’s apartment, there are disquieting signs: a green door that is locked, a computer that purrs with activity, and the omniscient game that knows too much and remembers even more.

Where is the line drawn between: Did Cameron program the game, or did the game program Cameron?

In like every episode of Black Mirror, Plaything refuses to offer an answer, which constitutes its brilliance. In the same manner as The Entire History of You and White Bear, this episode thrives in ambiguity. Cameron’s monotonous feelings and robotic existence are transformed by the psychological blade known as the game to something far more cruel, cold, and uncontrollable.

---

Aesthetic dualities and tonal precision

Visually, there is much to unpack in this episode. The present-day sequences are sanitized and emotionally hollow, relating to the modern-day monotony of Cameron’s life. In contrast, the grainy and warm flashbacks to 1994 evoke painful nostalgia from childhood, VHS cassettes, and CRT monitors.

Still, the clinical version of the game, with its pixelated representation, creates horrifying discordant reality gaps, isolation from blissful ignorance, and imagination. Like a child’s drawing hiding something grotesque, it’s never quite what it seems.”

Unrestrained sadness gently tinged with reminiscence effortlessly transforms into techno-noir horror. Pankiw, returning from Joan Is Awful, describes enveloping silence where unnerving stillness looms and void suffocates movement. The sound design carries the most weight, merging low tones like digitally produced whines and deformed voices that linger and fade like life in a desolate void.

---

The horror of digital inheritance

“Plaything” explores a distinctly contemporary dread: what if our creations outlast us and comprehend us on a deeper level? What if our suffering serves as the design for something different?

This narrative doesn’t solely revolve around vengeance and remorse. It examines emotional sediment—the aspects we choose to forget within us, and how they can rupture, or even thrive, in the synthetic realms we construct.

At one point, a detective wonders whether Cameron was “controlling the game or being controlled by it”—and the answer lingers like a curse. Is it possible for an AI to inherit trauma? Can it be taught cruelty? Is it possible for it to love?

---

Capaldi and Gribben: A portrait in fracture

The silence that Capaldi brings to Cameron is more terrifying than a scream, all because of the weary gravity Capaldi imbues him with. It festers with suspense. Every movement and pause feels as if it was intentionally planned—and it was. Like a gentleman gingerly stepping over shards of glass.

Gribben, in contrast, plays the younger Cameron with a raw, bruised vulnerability. Collectively, they produce a hauntingly visceral image of a shattered consciousness. A consciousness fractured by terror, softened by dreams, and at the end, devoured by them.

---

Not grand, but profound

“Plaything” doesn't contain shocking moments like USS Callister or emotional beats like San Junipero. It lacks significant world-building or eye-catching concepts. What it offers instead is, perhaps, rarer in the Black Mirror universe: profound devastation. It is an intrusion of horror from the periphery, a sadness that spreads slowly over time.

The episode concludes, as with many Black Mirror episodes, in vagueness but not bewilderment. We cannot determine where Cameron finishes and the game starts, and perhaps that is the point. In a reality where identity is but a file with the potential to be copied, re-executed, or distorted, the one truth that perhaps holds value is this: pain does not vanish. It transforms.

---

Final verdict

This episode definitely deserves a full-on 10/10⭐

“Plaything” is not only a standout episode of Season 7—it is a chilling reminder of what makes Black Mirror so timeless: the psychological horror that lies within humanity's frailty and the repercussions of our digital actions.

What differentiates this episode is its emotional simplicity. There is no overarching technological dystopia; there is just a man who has succumbed to a virtual sanctuary crafted from a myriad of sufferings. It doesn’t spoon-feed the narrative but instead invites the audience to piece together its mosaic of trauma, memory, and compulsion. It is hauntingly still, utterly humane.

Gribben and Capaldi deliver Cameron’s character with opposing elements—raw and resigned. Their performances encapsulate the primary inquiry of the episode: where does a man end, and where does a simulation begin?

“Plaything,” unlike the other more grandiose episodes of the season, dares to linger. It does not attempt to shock viewers, but to bring attention to something deeply unsettling: the notion that the things we try to conceal beneath layers of code never remain concealed, and technology does not spare us from solitude; it exacerbates our reality.

With unsettling and profoundly heartfelt elements, Plaything encapsulates Black Mirror at its most impactful.