"ARE YOU JOKING": Love Island: All Stars fans react to Casey winning the second season of the show

Love Island: All Stars Season 2 is its finale episode on February 17, 2025, on ITV2. The finale of the reality show featured five finalist couples. It included Ekin-Su and Curtis, Gabby and Casey, Catherine and Omar, Elma and Sammy, and Grace and Luca.

Following the public voting, Gabby and Casey became the winning couple and won Love Island: All Stars Season 2. Fellow couples were:

• Grace and Luca on 2nd position
• Ekin-Su and Curtis on 3rd position
• Catherine and Omar on 4th position
• Elma and Sammy and 5th position.

Witnessing how Casey and Gabby were the winning couple, fans of the reality show took to social media platform X and shared their thoughts. Fans reacted to Casey's win, stating his earlier behavior with fellow participants and more.

One of the fans shared on X:

"CASEY LOVE ISLAND WINNER ARE YOU JOKING WTF #loveisland."

Another fan described Casey's win as:

"Gabby and Casey is insane LOOOL like i haven't been satisfied with a Love Island winner in YEARS #LoveIsland #loveislandallstars."

A fan slammed Casey for winning the reality show:

"casey is a love island winner. you can't be serious #loveislandallstars #loveisland."

Another fan commented:

"we could've had double winner Ekin-Su but you gave the fiddy k to mr third time looking for clout #loveisland."

One more fan shared:

"CONGRATULATIONS SAMMY FOR NO LONGER BEING THE WORST WINNER IN LOVE ISLAND HISTORY CASEY TOOK YOUR PLACE #loveisland #loveislandallstars."

An X user wrote:

"Love Island had to crown Casey the winner - they didn't want him back in the Summer #loveisland."

Another fan mentioned Ekin-Su and Catherine and reacted to the winning couple, Gabby and Casey:

"U got a bigger L hun, ur Catherine was behind Ekin, that's a win for me, Ekin is a queen and she remains one! Once a winner? now go shed some hot tears under the duvet #Loveisland."

Another fan reacted to the show's winner:

"Even the winner shock worst undeserving winner Ever #loveisland #loveislandallstars."

One more fan criticized Gabby's win on Love Island: All Stars Season 2:

"The UK love an insecure b*tch because why is Gabby a winner? Lol #loveislandusa #loveisland."

A netizen commented:

"After my top 2 candidates won 4th and 3rd I was just praying to God that it wouldn't be Casey and that's exactly what tf happened… #LoveIslandAllStars."

---

Love Island: All Stars Season 2: Casey and Gabby won the title and the prize money

Love Island: All Stars Season 2 Finale aired on February 17, 2025, revealing the much-awaited result of the show. After five weeks of ups and downs and various dynamic shifts, fans were eagerly waiting to know the winning couple.

The host, Maya Jama, revealed that the winners of Love Island: All Stars Season 2 were Casey O'Gorman and Gabby Allen. They won £50,000 prize money along with the title. As fans already know, the voting took place, and based on the public voting, the couple was crowned as the winning pair.

2nd position was grabbed by Grace and Luca, followed by Ekin-Su and Curtis in 3rd place. 4th was Catherine and Omar, while in 5th position were Elma and Sammy.

However, after Casey and Gabby were revealed as the Love Island: All Stars Season 2 winners, it didn't sit well with fans. Some of them took to social media platform X and shared their views via comments.

As seen in the reactions, some of the Love Island: All Stars fans criticized the show makers for announcing Casey as the winner. A few discussed how he was an "undeserving winner." A few of them were also hoping for their favorite Ekin-Su and Curtis to become the winners, which didn't happen as they were in third place.

---

To know more about everything that happened on Love Island: All Stars Season 2 Finale, fans can stream the reality show episode on ITVX.