Day 4 of the American Idol auditions went live on ABC on March 24, 2025, and many participants lit up the stage with their mesmerizing performances. While some made the entire hall stand up and praise, others made the judges, Katy, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie, emotional with their story. One such contestant who made everyone teary was Freddie McClendon.
The episode features a heartfelt lineup of original as well as famous songs from the participants. From ballads to country music, contestants ensured to deliver a complete, full-house show to the audience and the panel. The raw talent on the stage last night took everybody by surprise.
Many contestants received golden tickets to Hollywood after the judges commended them for their tenacity and raw skill. But not every performance resonated, which resulted in difficult choices and heartfelt farewells. The competition is getting intense as the final phases of the auditions draw closer.
Let's take a look at a quick recap of American Idol day 4 of auditions.
What happened on American Idol Season 23 Episode 4?
On March 24, 2025, day 4 of the American Idol auditions aired live on ABC, and numerous contestants enthralled the audience with their captivating performances. As competitors shared their personal stories and gave stirring vocal performances, judges Katy Perry, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan were clearly moved.
The night kicked off with a rendition of Chappell Roan's "Pink Pony Club" by Penny Samar, a 23-year-old cafe manager, a native of Williamsport, Pennsylvania. Although her ability to speak was clear, the judges suggested that she control her emotional outbursts to engage the audience more. Despite initial misgivings, Penny managed to get her Hollywood ticket.
After fleeing an abusive relationship, Jamier, a 19-year-old from Buffalo, New York, revealed his heartwarming story of helping his mother raise his younger brothers. He advanced to the following round because the judges were moved by his sincere performance.
22-year-old Anthem, Arizona musician Sophia Humbert performed a simple piano rendition of Underwood's "Before He Cheats." Although the judges recognized her potential, they advised her to give her performance more vigor to fully convey the meaning of the song.
The audition of Sam Sparks, a 25-year-old musician from Arkansas who was paralyzed from the waist down in a vehicle accident, was particularly noteworthy. Sparks sang an original song called "Colorado Gray." The judges unanimously decided to promote him to Hollywood because of his tenacity and distinctive rock sound.
19-year-old Freddie McClendon sang an original song in honor of his late father as the show came to a close. His moving performance brought Underwood to tears and demonstrated the powerful influence of intimate musical storytelling.
The American Idol Season 23 episode 4 was a celebration of talent, passion, and tenacity. Contestants put their all into every performance, whether it was an emotional cover or an original song, and it made a lasting effect on both the judges and the audience. The show's commitment to elevating real voices was highlighted by the exceptional auditions.
You can watch all the episodes of American Idol auditions on ABC.

Your perspective matters!
Start the conversation