American Idol Season 23 Episode 13 aired on April 27, 2025. The latest episode featured the Top 14 contestants' performances. They performed the songs from Rock & Roll Hall of Fame legends. Based on their performances, the audience voted for the contestants. Viewers also witnessed James Taylor as the guest mentor.
The top 14 artists who performed in the latest episode included:
Filo, Mattie Pruitt, Breanna Nix, John Foster, Desmond Roberts, Jamal Roberts, Amanda Barise, Canaan James Hill, Josh King, Thunderstorm Artis, Gabby Samone, Kolbi Jordan, Ché, and Slater Nalley. The episode also featured two eliminations, including Amanda Barise and Desmond Roberts.
American Idol Season 23 Episode 13 Recap: Top 14 contestants perform to get their spots in the Top 12
The latest American Idol Season 23 episode started with Carrie Underwood's performance. She performed as a Rock & Roll Hall of Fame inductee, Heart's Alone.
Filo, 23, performed The Beatles' song With a Little Help from My Friends. Lionel said that it was a "smackdown," while Carrie stated:
"Every week you are giving more entertainment value. It was a wonderful way to start the show."
Mattie Pruitt's rendition of Piece of My Heart by Janis Joplin. Carrie told her to find her "sass." Luke advised her not to get "scared" of herself and that it was one of his favorite performances from Mattie.
John Foster, 18, performed Elvis Presley's Jailhouse Rock, which Carrie appreciated. She noted that John's song choice was "great" and that he made it his "own."
"I knew you were in the zone. That boy knows what he's doin'!" said Lionel.
Desmond Roberts performed the Commodores' Jesus is Love. Listening to his song, Lionel said that Desmond found some "octaves" which he didn't sing, and that Desmond tried to take his song.
Next was Jamal Roberts, 27. He performed The Isley Brothers' Shout, Parts 1 & 2. Lionel Richie said that it was so "professional" and that he was "so good." For Amanda Barise's performance, she sang Michael Jackson's I Can't Help It. American Idol judge Carrie Underwood said that it was "incredible."
Canaan James Hill performed Aretha Franklin's Mary, Don't You Weep, to which Carrie reacted:
"Vocals were spot-on, but I think you cheated the system. I wanted to see you rock out! At some point, do the unexpected."
Lionel Richie said that it was "unbelievable."
Next performances were:
- Josh King, 24, performed Billy Joel's The Longest Time
- Thunderstorm Artis, 29, performed James Taylor's Fire and Rain
- Gabby Samone, 23, performed Whitney Houston's Saving All My Love for You
- Breanna Nix, 25, performed Journey's Open Arms
- Kolbi Jordan, 26, performed Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell's You're All I Need to Get By
- Slater Nalley, 18, performed Elton John's Your Song
- Ché, 28, performed James Brown's It's a Man's, Man's, Man's World.
American Idol Season 23 Episode 13 ended with the eliminations. Amanda Barise and Desmond Roberts were sent home.
The Top 12, including Kanaan, Gabby, Mattie, Thunderstorm, Kolbi, Josh, Slater, Breanna, John, Filo, Jamal, and Ché, advanced to the next phase of American Idol Season 23.
Viewers can stream the released American Idol Season 23 episodes on Hulu.