On March 23, 2025, American Idol Season 23 Episode 4 displayed varied talents as the auditions progressed. Judges Luke Bryan, Carrie Underwood, and Lionel Richie were treated to a range of performances that demonstrated the diversity and depth of the competitors this season. One particularly noteworthy audition was that of Virginia native Nina Daig, who enthralled the judges and the crowd with her passionate performance.
When Nina entered the stage to perform her own song, "Average Joe," she did so in a genuine and soulful way that touched everyone in the room. Judge Carrie Underwood praised her for taking a chance with an original piece because of her distinctive singing style and moving storytelling. She received a golden ticket to Hollywood after the judges commended her talent and promise.
Impressed by her performance, social media was swiftly used by fans to show their appreciation for Nina's audition. She received a lot of attention on Reddit and Twitter, with many users praising her emotional depth and uniqueness.
An admirer of American Idol Season 23 wrote,
"Experience or not, Nina’s heart was all we needed to hear. Can’t wait to see where this journey takes her #AmericanIdol"
Another comment from a fan read,
"Nina had the best voice ive heard so far. I did miss some of the show. But she was WAY better than than young girl from Tn. They didnt stall at all on her. I didnt understand that one. #AmericanIdol"
"Y’all you put through some questionable voices, and you’re really considering not pushing Nina through….#americanidol," a netizen posted.
Similar appreciations were shared by other fans of the American Idol.
A person shared on social media,
"Hard to believe Nina has never sang in front of people…I’m really glad that’s changed. The world needs to hear her voice and her songs. ❤️ #AmericanIdol"
Another tweet read,
"Wow Nina has an amazing voice and she’s a phenomenal song writer #AmericanIdol"
"Wow, Nina daig's original song is incredible, And it was an amazing original song #AmericanIdol," another social media comment read.
"A crazy, good songwriter" — American Idol's Luke Bryans reacts to Nina's audition
The judges of American Idol were captivated by Nina Daig's moving rendition of her original song, "Average Joe." The Virginia native made a lasting impression on Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan with her poignant storytelling and beautiful vocals. She clearly poured her personal experiences into her song, as evidenced by her sincere delivery and profound lyrics.
Luke Bryan acknowledged her innate talent by praising her, saying, "Love so many things about your voice. To write from that place, it's how you formulate the beginnings of being a crazy, good songwriter."
On social media, fans repeated his opinions, praising Nina's genuineness and forecasting that she will be one of the season's breakout stars.
Head to ABC and watch the episodes of American Idol Season 23 now!

Your perspective matters!
Start the conversation