"Actually insane": Love Island: All Stars fans criticize Casey's behavior with Catherine

Love Island: All Stars Season 2 aired its latest episode on February 11, 2025. The 30th episode of the ITVX show featured various questions that participants got to ask the viewers and get the public's opinion on them.

In one of the segments, cast members learned about Catherine and Omar's question for the public. It was for Casey. The question was if he was there for clout.

It was after the previous episode featured Harriett calling out Casey, claiming that he was there for clout. Fans must know that Casey's current appearance on the show is his third time in the Love Island franchise.

After learning about the question, Casey didn't take it well. While explaining the reason behind the question, Catherine was sharing the reason, but Casey cut her off. When she mentioned that she was still talking, he said he wouldn't let her.

Witnessing Casey's behavior and not letting Catherine share her side, Love Island: All Stars fans slammed Casey via social media platform X.

A fan wrote on X:

"Casey talking to a black woman like that in 2025 during Black History Month is actually insane. #LoveIsland #LoveIslandAllStars."

Another fan commented about Casey and Gabby:

"That Casey and Gabby know they won't last a week on the outside that's why they are reacting like this. Gabby is too old to be this naive. It's literally there, this is his third time in the villa and you think you will work out on the outside ??lol #LoveIsland #LoveIslandAllStars."

A netizen criticized Casey for his behavior:

"OH HELL nahhh if yall let Casey win after the way he was talking to Catherine i'll be pissed OFFF #LoveIslandAllStars #loveisland2025 #loveisland."

A person wrote about Casey:

"How no one flipped the table to get at Casey is beyond me. I don't care if the table is nailed down, you get at him. #LoveIsland."

A Love Island: All Stars fan slammed cast members for allowing Casey's behavior towards Catherine:

"UHHHHH IS ANYONE GONNA PULL CASEY UP FOR SPEAKING TO CATHERINE LIKE THAT? #LoveIsland #loveislandallstars."

A user mentioned cast members, including Casey, to go home:

"I want Elma & Sammie and Gabby & Casey out of the villa by Thursday! All 4 are messy, toxic, and don't deserve to be in the final 4 couples. #LoveIsland #LoveIslandAllStars."

A person slammed Casey for not letting Catherine speak:

"Someone said Casey talks to women like that because it makes Gabby feel less insecure, so let's see if he picks a fight with Grace. #LoveIslandAllStars #LoveIsland."

Another user criticized Casey:

"Casey telling Catherine not to talk…yeah I need him OUT. He interrupted Catherine explaining herself. #LoveIsland."

---

Love Island: All Stars Season 2 Episode 30: Omar and Catherine share their side while Gabby clashed

After learning about the question that Catherine and Omar had asked the viewers about Casey being on the show for "clout," Casey seemed visibly upset. When he asked them the reason, Catherine started to explain but was interrupted by Casey.

He mentioned that she "cut off" him first, and he won't let her speak. She asked Casey to let her speak, but he refused. Love Island: All Stars cast members were sitting around the table while the argument took place, however, nobody interfered.

Later, when Omar tried to share his and Catherine's side, he told Casey that they thought if viewers got the right answer, then it would help Casey and Gabby in their relationship. Omar mentioned that the couple would get reassurance through the answer. As a result, the "clout" thing would be done once and for all.

"Remember, they're watching. We obviously know that you're not here for that," said Omar.

Responding to that, Love Island: All Stars' Gabby jumped in the conversation and mentioned that if what Omar suggested doesn't happen, what if viewers turned out to be "savage" with their voting? She mentioned that, since Omar was Casey's friend, it wasn't justified that he "threw" his friend "under the bus."

Chiming in on that, Catherine said that the argument from Casey and Gabby was as if they knew that the public's opinion was not going to be favorable for them. Later on, the public's opinion was revealed. According to that, 44% of viewers said yes, and the rest, 56%, said no.

Seeing that, Love Island: All Stars' Harriett told Casey that the public also saw that he wasn't there for clout and reassured him.

---

Fans can witness the incident on Love Island: All Stars Season 2 Episode 30 on ITVX.