Every song on Selena Gomez ft. Benny Blanco's 'I Said I Love You First' album ranked

82nd Golden Globe Awards  Cocktail Hour - Source: Getty
Every song ranked on Selena Gomez's 'I Said I Love You First' album. (Photo by Jason Armond / Los Angeles Times via Getty Images)

Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco's much-awaited album 'I Said I Love You First' was released on March 21, 2025. The album comes four years after Selena's Spanish EP, Revelación. This marks the engaged couple's first collaborative album, but have previously joined hands on multiple songs, including hit singles, I Can't Get Enough and Same Old Love.

Before the album's release, the duo shared glimpses of the album, behind-the-scenes, and inspiration. In their conversation for Spotify's Countdown To I Said I Love You First, the duo spoke about their "natural" process, with Selena Gomez noting,

"It was very, like, 'This is on my mind. How does that make you feel?'"

Blanco added,

"Yeah, I felt like your personal journal."

While rankings is subjective to people's preferences and songs popularity on media, we are taking a look at all songs from I Said I Love You First. Gomez took to her Instagram to express gratitude towards Benny and all other contributors to the album.

Note: This article is based on the writer’s opinion. Do let us know which other items deserve to make the list.


All songs on Selena Gomez ft. Benny Blanco's 'I Said I Love You First' album ranked

Selena Gomez ft. Benny Blanco's I Said I Love You First features 14 tracks that revolve around multiple themes, including Selena's journey and relationships. Some tracks are reminiscent of Gomez's pop era, while others appear to have been sung in an intimate acoustic style.

14. I Said I Love You First

From the get-go, Selena's album appears to be a deeply personal memoir, with I Said I Love You First, setting the tone. The video shows an emotional throwback moment from Gomez's Disney days. The singer and actress is on the final day of her set of Wizards Of Waverly Place, where she expresses gratitude to everyone and describes them as her "launchpad." As the video progresses, a soulful and light piano plays in the background.


13. I Can't Get Enough ft. Tainy and J Balvin

youtube-cover

The duo have added one of the earliest collaborative singles I Can't Get Enough on the LP. While the song from 2019 has been released as it is, the YouTube video shows Gomez and Blanco's playful montage.


12. Do You Wanna Be Perfect?

youtube-cover

In a 38-second lyric video, Selena Gomez takes a dig at unrealistic standards linked to "perfectionism" on social media. The video ends with Gomez stating,

"Actually, just be who you are."

11. How Does It Feel To Be Forgotten

2025 Vanity Fair Oscar Party Hosted By Radhika Jones - Arrivals - Source: Getty. (Photo by Lionel Hahn/Getty Images)
2025 Vanity Fair Oscar Party Hosted By Radhika Jones - Arrivals - Source: Getty. (Photo by Lionel Hahn/Getty Images)

Selena Gomez embodies her confident self in How Does It Feel To Be Forgotten. The singer appears to encapsulate the feelings of someone who has been able to move on from a relationship. While fans claimed that it may have a connection with Selena's ex-relationships, this is only speculated.


10. Cowboy

youtube-cover

Cowboy has sensual undertones, describing young romantic love. In an interview with Spotify, Selena drew parallels with her older track and noted,

“Cowboy’ is my version of 'Good for You' but now."

She added,

“I don’t like to share it a lot, but I’m a very sensual person. And I love love and sometimes I put that into words and I can feel hot, and I love that feeling.”

9. You Said You Were Sorry

97th Annual Academy Awards - Arrivals - Source: Getty. (Photo by Frazer Harrison/WireImage)
97th Annual Academy Awards - Arrivals - Source: Getty. (Photo by Frazer Harrison/WireImage)

Through the album, Selena Gomez incorporates themes of empowerment and forming a healthy relationship with oneself. Per Elle, the song reportedly "ties" the ends of a past relationship. Gomez was aware that the lyrics of some songs may lead to speculations but she clarified in her interview with Spotify,

“I would like to say most of this album has nothing to do with what everyone may go to."

8. Don't Wanna Cry

youtube-cover

Selena Gomez sings pop melodies of Don't Wanna Cry. The lyrics reveal a person's experience after a breakup, but Selena Gomez hasn't revealed a specific subject. Additionally, the song has a retro vibe, like a few other songs on her album.


7. Don't Take It Personally

youtube-cover

The video of Don't Take It Personally shows Benny and Selena Gomez sharing an intimate moment. The slow ballad gradually builds up and indicates that the interest in love ends up choosing the singer.


6. Sunset Blvd

Sunset Blvd features a sensual and retro theme, with groovy beats. As indicated by the singers, the title is very personal and carefully selected as their "first date was on Sunset Blvd". Selena Gomez noted that the track will always be "special" to the couple.


5. Ojos Tristes

youtube-cover

Sampled from Spanish singer, Jeanette's song, El Muchacho de Los Ojos Tristes, the song has the most Spanish lyrics in the album. Selena sings about a sad boy who she is moving on from.


4. Scared Of Losing You

Selena Gomez dropped Scared Of Losing You in time for Valentine's Day this year and added glimpses of her and Benny's relationship. The MV was released just a few months after the couple announced their engagement. Gomez can be heard delicately talking about her fears in a romantic relationship.


3. Younger and Hotter Than Me

youtube-cover

While many may speculate that Younger and Hotter Than Me may be about romantic relationships, Benny Blanco clarified it can hold multiple meanings. Per Elle, in a Behind-The-Scenes video, Blanco revealed the difficulties of a young star and noted,

"People find new things to hold, they find new things they can pick up, and you’re kind of left in this world where you’re kind of in limbo where you’re either gonna make it to this next chapter in your life or you’re gonna fade off into obscurity, and it’s a lot of pressure, I feel, that’s put on people at such a young age.”

2. Bluest Flame ft Charli XCX

Per the Vulture, Charli and Blanco have previously collaborated with Selena Gomez on her hit single, Same Old Love. The trio come together again to deliver a track with electro vibes and an upbeat theme.


1. Call Me When You Break Up Feat. Gracie Adams

youtube-cover

Selena Gomez has fun with Gracie Abrams on Call Me When You Break Up. The song takes you to early creations by Gomez. Shot from the comfort of a bedroom, the duo appear to bring their playful sides to the fore.


Selena Gomez and Benny Blanco's new album puts the spotlight on the artist's musical chemistry. From sentimental ballads to sensual and retro tracks, the album feels like Selena and Benny's intimate creation. The duo described the process of creating the album with their "best friend".

What are your thoughts on the new album? Tell us in the comments below

Edited by Sohini Biswas
comments icon

What's your opinion?
Newest
Best
Oldest