Sam’s Club brings back cookie cakes: Details you need to know

Sam’s Club took to its Instagram to announce that it is bringing the cookie cake back in February 2025. The sweet treat features two rectangle-shaped cookies that have a layer of thick icing placed in the middle. The warehouse brand posted a video of a cookie cake decorated with February 2025 blue frosting. The video was captioned as

"Cookie cake is back. That's it. That's the post."

While the announcement was made on January 28, customers may have to contact their nearest Sam’s Club for availability. The double-layer cookie cake was abruptly discontinued in early 2024 after being sold for many years.

---

Sam’s Club is bringing back cookie cakes in February 2025

Due to unclear reasons, Sam’s Club discontinued its cookie cakes in 2024. Per Southern Living, many customers were unhappy with the decision and even wrote a petition on Change.org. The petition was able to garner 1800+ signatures, with a customer writing that it is not only a "treat" but also a "tradition" to share with others. While it is unclear if the petition led to the relaunch, cookie cake loyalists can rejoice as it is making a comeback.

Users took to the post shared by the wholesale brand and expressed their excitement. One user (@lifewithpaigenicole) wrote,

"My kids will be so happy!! Birthdays haven’t been the same without your cookie cakes. Will they be back in time for Valentine’s Day??"

Many customers hoped that the cookie cakes would be in time for Valentine's Day. Since the cookie cakes can be customized, customers can choose the print based on the occasion.

While it is unclear if the cookie cakes have been officially rolled out, customers can browse through the Bread and Bakery section for other sweet treats. From Valentine's Day celebration cupcakes to pastries, customers can place an order through the website or purchase them in-store.

---

Sam’s Club's Cookie Cake is making a comeback one year after it was discontinued. While the news was announced in January, many customers have yet to see it in the store or on the website. Customers expressed their hope to be able to purchase the Cookie Cake by Valentine's Day.

Have you tried the cookie cake before? Tell us in the comments below.