20 best NYC bagel spots ranked according to customers

20 best NYC bagel spots ranked according to customers

New Yorkers' love for bagels is unmatchable and there are a variety of NYC bagel shops. While bagel lovers always debate about the best places in the city to have them, many shops sell some of the best quality and delicious round bread in the city. Some of the best NYC bagel shops are given here which can help customers pick their favorite one.

20) Terrace Bagels & Cafe

Terrace Bagels & Cafe is situated in West Brooklyn in Windsor Terrace. It is one of the best NYC bagel shops that sell traditional bagels. Their rolled breads are fluffy and filled with flavors that burst into one's mouth. What makes them special is that these bagels are simple and authentic, and New Yorkers enjoy them.

19) Tompkins Square Bagels

Tompkins Square Bagels has three different in East Village. While this NYC bagel shop has been in business for a long time now, its menu has some simple options such as plain, poppy, as well as pumpernickel. However, they also have some special options like chocolate chips, French toast, and more.

18) Modern Bread & Bagel

Modern Bread & Bagel is another NYC bagel shop that sells some of the most dense and chewy breads. These big pockets of air have a taste that grows on customers, and they then return to buy another piece. What makes this shop special is that it sells gluten-free bagels, which are quite popular among customers.

17) Bagel Hole

It has been decades since Bagel Hole has been selling delicious bagels in NYC. This bagel shop in Park Slope does not roast its bagels but simply bakes and sells them. They have 11 varieties of doughs from which customers can pick. Since 1985, this bagel shop has been selling these yummy breads, and they have not changed.

16) Bergen Bagels

Bergen Bages is another bagel shop in Brooklyn that does not sell toasted bagels. However, they offer the option to toast them to meet customers' demands. Their warm and chewy bagels are perfect for breakfast and can be stuffed with cream cheese, red onions, whitefish salad, or tomato. Customers can also ask for all these fillings at once.

15) Broad Nosh Bagels

Broad Nosh Bagels, located on the Upper West Side in New York City, is always busy with people crowding the place for their bagel sandwiches. They serve a variety of sandwiches with a number of vegetables, including avocado and microgreens. They also add meat to their toasted bagels and offer some French delicacies as well.

14) Greenberg's Bagels

Greenberg's Bagel is one of the most popular NYC bagel shops. The bagel shop has two locations: one is in Bed Stuy, while the second is in the West Village. While their bagels are very famous across the city, this spot is also known for selling all kinds of breakfast options, such as eggs, sandwiches, sausage, and more.

13) Best Bagel & Coffee

Best Bagel & Coffee is located on the 35th Street in New York City. This cozy place sells puffy and chewy bagels that taste sweet. What makes it special and customers' favorite is that its bagels are absolutely fresh and are often served piping hot right from the oven. Besides bagels, they also have a wide variety of dishes on the menu.

12) Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagel

Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagel has been in the business for almost 14 years and, with time, has become a popular place in Brooklyn. It is one of the most loved NYC bagel shops as its chef sells round bread with seafood. The shop has a seafood expert who can make all kinds of seafood stuffings.

11) Bagel Pub

Bagel Pub is another destination in New York, which is a perfect spot for Sunday brunch. It is often crowded with people ordering their bagel sandwiches with exceptional spreads, including za'atar cream cheese, their most popular and customers' favorite. Despite the rush, they ensure to serve piping hot bagels.

10) PopUp Bagels

While PopUp Bagels began in the backyard in Connecticut, they have spread their wings across the city with three more locations. This NYC bagel shop sells fresh bagels, which are thin yet fluffy. While they stick to selling traditional-style bagels, they also ensure these breads are loaded with flavors. Scallion and cinnamon sugar are two of their most recommended flavors.

9) Bagels & Co

Bagels & Co is something that looks and smells like a pizza place. However, they sell some of the most delicious bagels in the city. They have two locations in the city: one is on 1428 York Avenue, while the second is on 391 Amsterdam Avenue. They have a wide variety of spicy and sweet stuffings.

8) Bo's Bagels

Bo's Bagels is the only bagel shop in Harlem. What makes them the favorite spot for customers is their glossy bagels, which look absolutely scrumptious. However, it is not all about appearance. Bo's Bagels serves round breads, which are also dense, chewy, and plump. Besides Harlem, they also have another location in Washington Heights.

7) Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe

While the name suggests that Olde Brooklyn Bagel Shoppe is old-fashioned, it is certainly not. This NYC bagel shop stands out in every way as it sells some of the best-tasting breads. This shop is mainly known for its za'atar bagels, which are traditional round breads with a zesty flavor.

6) Liberty Bagels

Liberty Bagels near Penn Station in NYC is mostly packed with customers; therefore, most opt for go-to orders. From spicy to savory and sweet, they have all kinds of options for customers and a wide variety of fillings. Those with a sweet tooth can opt for Oreo cream cheese flavor.

5) Apollo Bagels

Apollo Bagels is located on 10th Street in New York and is one of the most beloved spots of customers. They do not let their bagels cool down but rather serve them at oven temperature. They have multiple locations across the city, including 242 E.10th Street, 133 N. 7th Street, and 73 Greenwich Ave.

4) Mike's Bagels

Mike's Bagels is another popular NYC bagel shop serving delicious breads. This spot is perfect for those who enjoy a heavy breakfast and love having delicious bagels. Mike's Bagels offers a variety of doughs; however, their poppy and whole wheat ones are their bestsellers. For breakfast, their dark pumpernickel bagel is also a great option.

3) Utopia Bagels

Utopia Bagels is definitely in the top three when it comes to the best NYC bagel shops. This shop has been in the business since 1980 and is thriving in the busy city for all the right reasons. Their bagels are perfectly flavored as no ingredient overpowers one another but blends perfectly to bring out a delicious rolled bread.

2) Knickerbocker Bagel Brooklyn

So far, it has been clear that Brooklyn has some of the best NYC bagel shops, and Knickerbocker Bagel must top that list. Their bagels are not only soft and chewy but also crispy at some level as one pushes them down. These big and fluffy bagels are enough to feed an individual as they are filled with flavors.

1) Ess-a-bagel

New York City's most puffy bagels are sold at Ess-a-bagel. For the unversed, they are also one of the oldest NYC bagel shops as they were established in 1976. These bagels are slightly sweet, crispy on the outside, and fluffy and chewy on the inside. Bagel lovers must check out this popular spot in the city.