1.McLoons Lobster Shack - South Thomaston

The winner of this list is McLoon, a place that has claimed its spot among many lists on social media and even Reddit as one of the best places in Maine to get Lobster Rolls. This family-owned lobster shack eludes a friendly vibe; you can choose to have the warm butter lobster rolls, the mayo one, or both.
Edited by Zainab Shaikh