17 best key lime pie spots in Florida

17 best key lime pie spots in Florida

Florida's iconic lime pie, known for its creamy filling and tart key limes, is a must-try treat when you visit the Sunshine State. From traditional recipes to modern twists, the pie has been there for years. The list has the best lime pies the Sunshine State has to offer.

Disclaimer: This piece reflects the writer's opinion; the reader's discretion is advised. Do let us know in the comments what you think should have made the cut.

17. Blue Heaven

Blue Heaven, in Key West, Florida, is a restaurant and bar that opened in 1992. It's known for its food, drinks, and live music. What makes it more famous is its 'Famous Key Lime Pie.' Only for $9.75, it's a must-try when you're in the area. The official website also sells merchandise for its fans.

16. Mattheessen’s

Opened in 1993, Mattheessen’s is a must-visit for any sweet lover. They don't stop with ice cream, cookies, or fudge; they also serve Florida's Lime Pie. Their lime pie is made of a homemade, thick graham cracker crust, which is paired with a tart lime filling. Other than this, they also serve a frozen lime pie that is dipped in Belgian chocolate on a stick.

15. Kermit’s Key Lime Shop

Kermit's Key Lime Shop, located at 200 Elizabeth St, Key West, is famous for its lime pie. Serving not just the traditional lime pie but adding modern twists like Strawberry Key Lime Pie, Coconut Key Lime Pie, and Key Lime Pie and Pie Bar Combo. Also, they haven't forgotten you if you have gluten sensitivities; they also offer gluten-free key lime pie. You can expect to shell out around $40 for a pie.

14. Old Town Bakery

This bakery was opened by Bowen and his wife in 2010. Located at the corner of Eaton and Grinnell, 930 Eaton Street, Key West, Florida. This bakery is famous for its sandwiches and, of course, lime pie. It was voted as the best Miami New Times Key Lime Pie in the Keys.

13. Thai Island Key West

This Thai restaurant at 711 Eisenhower Dr., Key West, Florida, is famous for serving the best Thai and sushi food in the area. Surprisingly they also serve lime pie, but with a twist: they add coconut milk instead of using cream or meringue, just for 10.95. A must-visit place if you're in the mood for some sushi and dessert.

12. Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar

Located at 7001 Shrimp Road, Key West, this place serves the best coastal food in all of Key West. It serves Key Lime bread pudding, which is made up of coconut gelato and crème anglaise. They also serve a drink called the Key Lime Martini, which was influenced by the key lime pie. The place to visit for some amazing seafood, amazing dessert, and also for amazing drinks.

11. Key Lime Pie Bakery

Key Lime Pie Bakery is a locally owned gem located at 412 Greene St, Key West. The bakery specializes in Key Lime Pies topped with their signature homemade cream, which are baked daily. Other than being famous for their Key Lime Pies, they're also famous for their Key Lime-flavored cakes, cookies, and tea. Definitely a place to check out if you love Key Lime Pie.

10. El Meson de Pepe

El Meson de Pepe has been serving Cuban cuisine in Key West since 1979. Known for serving the best Cubano in the area, they also serve their version of the Key Lime Pie, or should I say Torta de Limon, which is slightly lighter and less tart. This established Cuban eatery not only has delicious food but also a vibrant cultural experience.

9. The Stoned Crab

The restaurant, established in 2019, has been serving the people of Key West fresh seafood straight from their fishing boats. Serving only the best of pink shrimp, stone crab, and lobster, the place is a must-try for seafood. Their key lime pie is also something worth trying here.

8. Key West Key Lime Pie Co.

Key West Lime Pie Co. is a must-visit place in Key West. The place has won numerous awards for its pies. The place adds modern twists to the classic key lime pie, with additions like toasted coconut, mango, and blueberry. This is the place to visit when you're bored of having the same old lime pie.

7. Moondog Cafe & Bakery

Moondog Cafe & Bakery serves one of the best key lime pies in Key West. Established almost seven years ago, the place has been serving the people of the Sunshine State decadent food. Other than their key lime pie, the 'Moondog Classic' is also a must-try, loved by the people.

6. Hogfish Bar & Grill

Located on Stock Island, the place serves fresh seafood, strong drinks, and also has a waterfront view. Hogfish Bar & Grill, established in 2002, has been serving the people of Stock Island with the best seafood and also key lime pies, making it a spot worth seeing.

5. Joe’s Stone Crab

This iconic South Beach eatery has been serving the people of Florida for more than 110 years with its iconic food. This place has become a legend for the food it serves. Famous for its fish sandwiches and key lime pies. Fun fact: this restaurant has been around since before Miami Beach was even established as a city. Do visit this iconic place whenever you're around 11 Washington Ave.

4. Donut Hole Bakery and Cafe

The Donut Hole Bakery and Cafe is located at 635 Harbor Boulevard in Destin, Florida. Their donut holes, which mix strong espresso, smooth, velvety chocolate, and a bit of caramel, do justice to their name. If you visit this spot, don't forget to indulge in their Key Lime pie, known for its perfect balance of creamy and tart flavors.

3. Contenti Cupcakes

This mobile trailer serves one of the best key lime pies. It's so good that they take a limited amount of orders, and to place an order, you have to do it 72 hours before. Other than pies, Contenti Cupcakes also serves cupcakes and cakes.

2. Fireman Derek’s Bake Shop

Located at 2545 N. Miami Ave, the place is owned by Miami firefighter-turned-pie-expert Derek Kaplan. One of the best cake shops in all of Florida. They serve pies, cakes, cheesecakes, cookies, and baked goodies. Fireman Derek's key lime pie is also famous, making it a must-try when you're in Florida.

1.Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen

Established in 1976, Mrs. Mac's Kitchen is considered to serve the best key lime pie in the Keys. A fan favorite, including both locals and tourists for over 40 years, known for its homemade burgers, sandwiches, and, of course, key lime pies. At $7 for a slice of the best key lime pie—what more could you ask for?