Should ketchup go in the fridge or the cupboard? Heinz ends the debate once and for all

Heinz Ketchup - Source: Getty
Representational image of Heinz ketchup - Source: Getty

The heated argument about ketchup storage continues since Heinz reintroduced this long-standing question: should ketchup go in the refrigerator or remain on kitchen shelves? The controversy surrounding ketchup storage has a growing audience of concerned individuals.

And before you say, “Who cares?”—trust us, people do. They care a lot.

In a move that sent shockwaves through condiment cabinets worldwide, Heinz declared that "Ketchup. goes. in. the. Fridge!!!" Yes, they went full caps lock, and you know things are serious when brands start talking.


The fridge squad

For several years, refrigerator loyalists have used their ketchup-stained insignia to advocate that the bottle requires cold storage. The label directly warns you to place ketchup in a refrigerator after opening it in order to get the best results.

Case closed, right?

These fridge-first purists argue that keeping ketchup cold preserves its tangy, sweet perfection while preventing any microscopic villains from setting up camp inside the bottle.

They also have science on their side. Heinz spokesperson Olivia Lennon explained to MailOnline that while ketchup’s natural acidity keeps it shelf-stable before opening, all bets are off once that seal is broken.

"There was only ever one correct answer," Lennon said.
"Our ketchup has to be in the fridge."

The cupboard clan

Armed with a single, devastating counterpoint: "What about restaurants?" These ketchup anarchists insist that if diners can leave their bottles out all day and still live to tell the tale, then there’s no reason to turn your fridge into a ketchup igloo at home.

Their other key argument is preservatives. Ketchup is loaded with vinegar, sugar, and salt. Cupboard supporters claim this means ketchup can survive outside the fridge without turning into a science experiment.


Numbers don’t lie (but they do stir the pot)

A poll conducted by Heinz UK in 2023 saw 13178 people wade into the great ketchup war. 63.2% said fridge, while 36.8% swore by cupboard storage.

The brand has basically taken the stance of a strict parent who insists, "Because I said so."


The public meltdown

Social media exploded with hot takes and people threatening to disown family members over ketchup placement. X threads became battlegrounds.

Meanwhile, grocery stores and restaurants have been left in the crossfire. If ketchup must be refrigerated, why is it sold on shelves? And why do restaurants let it bask in fluorescent lighting all day?

Heinz clarified that sealed bottles are fine at room temp, but once opened, the cold embrace of the fridge is ketchup’s only true home.


The chef’s take

Culinary experts side with Team Fridge, arguing that refrigeration locks in the optimal flavor. Others, however, argue that cold ketchup is an assault on the senses, making it harder to drizzle over food and dampening the taste.

At the end of the day, this debate is bigger than ketchup. It’s about tradition.

The ketchup debate requires a commitment to guard the defined ketchup boundary without compromise.

People identify themselves by their ketchup preservation choices, whether they choose refrigeration or cupboard storage. Choose wisely.

Edited by Sarah Nazamuddin Harniswala
comments icon

What's your opinion?
Newest
Best
Oldest