"Please no more musicals..." - Netizens react hilariously as Jesse Eisenberg’s next film is set to be a musical comedy

Storytellers - Kieran Culkin In Conversation With Jesse Eisenberg - 2024 Tribeca Festival - Source: Getty
Storytellers - Kieran Culkin In Conversation With Jesse Eisenberg - 2024 Tribeca Festival - Source: Getty

Jesse Eisenberg, who was already an established Hollywood actor with notable films like The Social Network, the Now You See Me trilogy, Batman v Superman, and more, surprised moviegoers when he stepped behind the camera to write and direct the critically acclaimed gem A Real Pain - a film that even earned him an Oscar nomination for Best Original Screenplay at the 97th Academy Awards. Now, the 41-year-old is gearing up for his next venture, and fans just got some exciting new details.

Jesse Eisenberg’s next film will be a musical comedy for A24. The untitled project follows a woman who gets cast in a community theater musical, only to completely lose herself in the role. Starring Julianne Moore, Paul Giamatti, Halle Bailey, Colton Ryan, Havana Rose Liu, and Bernadette Peters, the film began production in April. The news has moviegoers buzzing with excitement, eager to see what Eisenberg has up his sleeve after the success of A Real Pain.


Hilarious Internet Reactions

Moviegoers had their own hilarious theories and predictions about the film, and wasted no time taking to the internet to share them.

"Please no more musicals... Ugh.... Nails on a chalkboard," a user wrote.

This user clearly isn’t a fan of musicals. The hate must be real if they’re comparing it to nails on a chalkboard!

"Imagine “black swan” but for local theater and everyone sings their breakdowns," pointed another.

If you’re wondering what Jesse Eisenberg’s musical comedy for A24 might be like, this user has quite the take - imagine Black Swan but set in a local theater, and everyone sings their breakdowns!

Paul Giamatti for the win! (via @IanDavidNoakes / X)

Actor Paul Giamatti is best known for his work in drama, but when he does venture into comedy, he absolutely delivers, as this GIF proves. So, fans are all lined up to see what he brings to a musical comedy.

"I can’t wait to see him at the Daily Planet," a user said.

Jesse Eisenberg was quite memorable as Lex Luthor in Zack Snyder’s Batman v Superman - so much so that this user seems convinced they might spot him next in the Daily Planet, the iconic fictional newspaper from the DC universe.

"So basically Whiplash meets Glee, but make it uncomfortably A24," commented another.

A musical comedy for A24 directed by Jesse Eisenberg? That sounds like it could be a wild mix of Whiplash meets Glee!

The news of Jesse Eisenberg’s new film being a musical comedy with a star-studded ensemble cast has definitely piqued the interest of moviegoers. And based on his previous work, it’s safe to expect something smart, witty, and feel-good all at once.

Edited by Sohini Biswas