"I'm sorry that's hilarious": Internet reacts as Amanda Seyfried reveals she auditioned for Wicked alongside Cynthia Erivo

In a revelation that has left fans both amused and fascinated, Amanda Seyfried recently opened up about auditioning for the movie Wicked alongside none other than powerhouse vocalist Cynthia Erivo.

The Mamma Mia! star shared her experience in a candid interview, recalling the surreal moment of singing with Erivo, even though she ultimately didn’t land the role. “I got to sing with her, and that was a moment in itself,” she said, reflecting on the audition.

@olwestside's tweet captured the collective reaction:

"This is actually insane 😭😭😭," as people marveled at the unexpected pairing.

To add a little spice to the mix, Erivo cheekily remarked that she was relieved Ariana Grande was cast as Glinda, saying, “Thank goodness, because it was not the two ladies that I was auditioning with.”

Of course, the focus quickly turned to Seyfried’s vocal ability compared to that of Cynthia Erivo, with @SCARLETTOLOGYY tweeting,

"I’m sorry that’s hilarious 😭 bc she probably said it in terms of vocal ability."

---

From Mean Girls to Wicked auditions: Amanda Seyfried’s unexpected moment with Cynthia Erivo has fans in stitches

As soon as Amanda Seyfried’s Wicked audition confession hit the internet, fans wasted no time sharing their thoughts. The news sparked a mix of surprise, laughter, and a touch of shade. One user, @Lil_Luna_IRL said,

"imo ariana was perfect for the role, definitely the right pick

While @ashleighm1chelle added fuel to the fire by saying,

"and she ain't get it for a reason she gotta move on". Ouch.

@chaniofficial2 wrote,

"Ohh she didn't have to do Cynthia dirty..."

Despite Seyfried’s talent, it seems the internet couldn’t help but joke about the comparison between her and Erivo, a Tony Award winner known for her jaw-dropping performances.

@gh0sst1n defended Amanda, saying,

"You guys are so nasty to her she’s literally Karen from Mean Girls, y’all cmon now."

@Asian_sunny said,

"can she just accept the fact that Ariana got the role and she didn’t? We’re TIRED 😭😭”

While the internet can be harsh, it’s clear Seyfried’s audition story resonated with fans who couldn't stop laughing at the thought of her belting out tunes next to a vocal powerhouse like Erivo. The contrast between their vocal ranges became a running joke online, but fans couldn’t deny Seyfried’s courage for even auditioning for such a role.

---

The audition process: Singing with Cynthia Erivo

Going back to the beginning, the Wicked auditions were as demanding as you might think. Singing with Cynthia Erivo was intimidating and amazing, according to Amanda Seyfried. Naturally, the expectations were high for a movie version of a popular Broadway musical. While Erivo secured the coveted role of Elphaba, the green-skinned witch with a massive singing range, Seyfried’s audition didn’t go unnoticed—her talent just wasn’t quite the match for Wicked's vocal demands.

Cynthia Erivo remarked that she wasn't shocked by the choice and that she had no reservations about Ariana Grande being selected as Glinda. Erivo said she was relieved that she wouldn't be on screen with the two other actors she auditioned with, which was probably a reference to Seyfried and another unidentified actress. Although Seyfried's feelings on the ultimate casting have not been disclosed, her remarks imply that she accepted the situation graciously and was appreciative of the chance.

The audition process for Wicked has been highly secretive, but Seyfried’s recent revelations have shed light on just how competitive it was. Although she didn’t land the role, Amanda seemed thrilled to have the chance to sing alongside Cynthia Erivo, calling it “a moment in itself.” And for fans, Seyfried’s willingness to poke fun at her own audition mishap made the story even more endearing.