The Zodiac Killer remains one of the most chilling figures in true crime history. His terror runs deep into the American psyche. Even after decades now, this cold case is still “warm” because of how fascinating it is to the public.
The Zodiac Killer is perhaps the most mysterious and twisted figure, who absolutely terrorized Northern California's Bay Area in the late 1960s. There is no confirmed number of killings when it comes to the Zodiac. He did not just kill, but also wrote cryptic letters and ciphers to the authorities.
In popular culture, he has become an infamous figure who has inspired numerous books and movies. What seems like the most memorable portrayal is the 2007 David Fincher movie called Zodiac. It is based on the book and the investigation done by cartoonist Robert Graysmith.
But, what exactly makes this case and the film so compelling? Here are five harrowing details about the real-life Zodiac Killer. who still haunts the world of unsolved crimes.
Disclaimer: The article reflects the author's opinion. Reader discretion is advised.
Five harrowing details about the real-life Zodiac Killer
1) He taunted the authorities
Perhaps, the most disturbing thing about the Zodiac Killer was the fact that he was brazen when it came to interacting with the public, though not in person, of course. He would send letters to local newspapers and fill them with threats, cryptic messages and puzzles to confuse the authorities, right after his ruthless crimes.
It would be wrong to call these letters 'confessions'. They can be rather considered as chilling messages that only exuded his arrogance. This was brought to life on the screens in the movie, Zodiac.
The first letter was sent on August 1, 1969, to the San Francisco Chronicle, Vallejo Times-Herald, and San Francisco Examiner. Every letter had a cryptogram that the Zodiac claimed, if deciphered, would reveal his identity. However, nobody could decipher it.
What’s even more horrifying is how the Zodiac demanded that these letters should be printed on the front page of the newspapers. If his demands were not met, he would threaten to kill more people.
This clearly showed that the Zodiac was more interested in instilling fear and terror in the public. And, to be honest, he successfully did so. Fincher’s movie portrayed this tension in the media outlets, how the letters made them panic and how it fueled their obsession to catch him.
2) He used cryptic ciphers and puzzles
Well, now that it was public knowledge that the Zodiac killer could not get his fill from the murders; it became obvious that he wanted to toy with the police, the media, and in fact, everybody. He wanted the world to fear him.
Hence, his letters would contain these cryptograms that he challenged others to solve. He sent four ciphers and out of them, two have been solved. The most famous of these ciphers is the Z408.
This cipher was cracked by a couple: a school teacher and his wife, Donald Harden and Bettye. As expected, it carried a disturbing message that claimed that he was collecting slaves for the afterlife. If not anything, one thing was certain, he believed a lot in astrology.
The movie Zodiac, brilliantly showed how frustrated and obsessed the journalists, amateur detectives and others became with the pursuit of these ciphers. This also added to the mythos of the Zodiac as not only a killer, but a game-master with a twisted psyche who enjoyed playing games with people.
3) His identity remains a mystery till date
Despite spending an enormous amount of time (decades) in searching for the true identity of the killer, Zodiac is still a mystery. The efforts of the law enforcement and civilians are highlighted in Fincher’s movie.
This case saw a number of suspects, but there is no conclusive information on the same. Till date, no definitive proof has ever linked anyone to the crimes.
One of the main and most popular suspects was Arthur Leigh Allen. He was an elementary school teacher. Allen was suspected by the detective and also deeply scrutinized. According to reports, there was some circumstantial evidence that connected him to the Zodiac.
However, as mentioned before, nothing conclusive ever saw the light of the day. Nothing confirmed him officially to identify him as the infamous killer. The movie Zodiac, masterfully shows the frustration that plagued this investigation. Especially affected were Robert Graysmith and Inspector Dave Toschi. They always felt close to solving the case and yet far.
4) He was methodical and unpredictable
If we were to recall one of the Zodiac’s most terrifying kills, it would be the one that took place on September 27, 1969, at Lake Berryessa. He met a young couple, Bryan Hartnell and Cecelia Shepard, as they were picnicking. But this time, he would do something different. Instead of doing his usual, which was shooting the victims, this time, he wore a hood and used a knife.
He ordered Shepard to tie up Hartnell before he began stabbing them multiple times. Surprisingly, Hartnell survived this horrific incident and provided some details of the encounter. Described as a white male, dressed in a bizarre outfit of a black hood with sunglasses over the eyeholes, the man had a bib-like piece on his chest and there was a white symbol on it.
He had a gun with him, which according to reports, Hartnell said looked like a .45. The Zodiac claimed that he was an escaped convict from a jail somewhere in Colorado or Montana.
He also said that he had killed a guard and stolen a car. But, the car was “too hot”, so now he needed money and a vehicle to get to Mexico. After the attack, the Zodiac drew his signature symbol on Bryan’s car door and jotted some dates along with the mention of “by knife” to indicate how he attacked the victims on those dates.
What’s even more shocking is that he called the Napa County Sheriff's Department from a payphone not long after. He told the operator calmly, that he was calling to:
"Report a murder—no, a double murder."
Then he confessed. The detectives later managed to lift a palm print from the phone, but it did not lead to anyone.
After two weeks, the Zodiac killer got into a taxi driven by Paul Stine in downtown San Francisco. After 15 minutes, he shot Stine in the head and likely killed him on the spot.
After a few weeks, the Zodiac sent a seven-page letter where he claimed that just after three minutes of him shooting Stine, two police officers even stopped and spoke to him. But, they had no clue who he was.
In the letter, he also threatened to blow up a school bus. He even boastfully claimed that nobody will ever be able to catch him because he had been “too clever for them”. This shows how methodical Zodiac is and how his unpredictability made him even more dangerous.
5) He made people obsessed with him
Robert Graysmith is a name that will forever be tied to the Zodiac killer. He was a cartoonist for the San Francisco Chronicle. His obsession with the case is perfectly depicted in Fincher’s movie.
Graysmith became engrossed in the case after he saw the killer’s taunting letters to the authorities. This obsession gave birth to two books that ultimately provided the foundation to the movie.
For Graysmith, this was becoming a consuming fixation. One that interfered with his day-to-day life. Zodiac’s cryptic messages, the lack of a clear suspect, and the ongoing taunts to top it all, made the mystery even more haunting and alive.
This was no longer just about the crimes committed, but also the haunting enigma of the killer who left more questions than answers.
The atmosphere of fear and obsession surrounding the Zodiac killer is potent even today. The legacy of the case still attracts curiosity and speculation. The Zodiac will always be a dark stain on true crime history.
Stay tuned to Soap Central for more updates and detailed coverage.