15 Psycho thrillers scary enough to haunt you for days

By Ekparna Podder

Modified Jan 09, 2025 17:59 ET

Shutter Island | Image via Paramount Pictures

3) Shutter Island

Shutter Island | Image via: Paramount Pictures

Shutter Island is a Martin Scorsese film that is sure to make you question your sanity. It is a powerful portrayal of trauma and fractured identity, fueled by the raging, stormy setting and oppressive background score. Leonardo DiCaprio in the role of Teddy Daniels (or Andrew Laeddis) rightfully depicts how grief and mental damage can distort one's sense of the self to escape a scarring past. The intricate narrative leading up to the devastating revelation and of course, the climactic quote "Which would be worse: to live as a monster, or to die as a good man?" — leaves an open ending for the audience to question everything they'd seen so far.

Shop the Looks of Your Favorite Stars Shop All

Nick’s brown jacket by Theory

Nick’s brown jacket by Theory

As seen on Joshua Morrow in Y&R

$695 at Saks Fifth Avenue

Leo’s navy and green striped sweater by Trina Turk

Credits: Peacock

Leo’s navy and green striped sweater by Trina Turk

As seen on Greg Rikaart in DOOL

$249 at Trina Turk

Audra’s light peach trench coat by Significant Other

Audra’s light peach trench coat by Significant Other

As seen on Zuleyka Silver in Y&R

Chelsea’s Cotton Blend Tote Bag by H&M

Chelsea’s Cotton Blend Tote Bag by H&M

As seen on Melissa Claire Egan in Y&R

Chelsea’s cream checked coat by DKNY

Chelsea’s cream checked coat by DKNY

As seen on Melissa Claire Egan in Y&R

$209.99 at Macys

Chelsea’s black and brown printed shirtdress by Rails

Chelsea’s black and brown printed shirtdress by Rails

As seen on Melissa Claire Egan in Y&R

$268 at Nordstrom

Nate’s leather jacket by John Varvatos

Nate’s leather jacket by John Varvatos

As seen on Sean Dominic in Y&R

$598 at John Varvatos

Lois’s black chevron fair-isle sweater by All Saints

Credits: Peacock

Lois’s black chevron fair-isle sweater by All Saints

As seen on Rena Sofer in GH

$209.25 at Nordstrom

Sophia’s green striped star sweater by Urban Outfitters

Credits: Peacock

Sophia’s green striped star sweater by Urban Outfitters

As seen on Madelyn Kientz in DOOL

Tate’s navy plaid button down shirt by All Saints

Credits: Peacock

Tate’s navy plaid button down shirt by All Saints

As seen on Leo Howard in DOOL

$221.61 at Zappos

Rachel’s white floral smocked dress by Zunie

Credits: Peacock

Rachel’s white floral smocked dress by Zunie

As seen on Finley Rose Slater in DOOL

Ava’s floral Floral Peasant Top by Rag & Bone

Credits: Peacock

Ava’s floral Floral Peasant Top by Rag & Bone

As seen on Tamara Braun in DOOL

$123 at Saks Fifth Avenue

Tessa’s red coat by Simkhai

Tessa’s red coat by Simkhai

As seen on Cait Fairbanks in Y&R

$995 at Revolve

Phyllis’s brown twist front ruched dress by Ronny Kobo

Phyllis’s brown twist front ruched dress by Ronny Kobo

As seen on Michelle Stafford in Y&R

$470.40 at Saks Fifth Avenue

Summer’s black button front leather dress by L'Agence

Summer’s black button front leather dress by L'Agence

As seen on Allison Lanier in Y&R

$595 at Saks Fifth Avenue

Mariah’s brown checked coat by DKNY

Mariah’s brown checked coat by DKNY

As seen on Camryn Grimes in Y&R

$299.99 at Macys

Mariah’s Striped Sweater by DKNY

Mariah’s Striped Sweater by DKNY

As seen on Camryn Grimes in Y&R

$49.50 at Macys

Sally’s classic jolene bag by Pinko

Sally’s classic jolene bag by Pinko

As seen on Courtney Hope in Y&R

$355 at Farfetch

Sally’s plaid skirt by Maje

Sally’s plaid skirt by Maje

As seen on Courtney Hope in Y&R

$45.99 at Nordstrom

Stephanie’s blue wrap mini dress by Maje

Credits: Peacock

Stephanie’s blue wrap mini dress by Maje

As seen on Abigail Klein in DOOL

Comment

Edited by Apoorva Jujjavarapu