10 worst comebacks in British soap history

Dramatic storylines are an indispensable part of soap operas. British soap operas are known for their long-running shows with intricate plots, and the key ingredient in these long-running shows is comebacks. A successful comeback can make or break a character. Characters who were once thought to be gone forever have a knack for reappearing in soap operas.

This makes the viewers anticipate whether the departure of any character is truly a final departure or whether they are going to return with a bigger appeal. However, sometimes the comebacks are not able to reignite the drama and captivate the audience like they once were able to do. Sometimes, comebacks fall flat, leaving the viewers disappointed.

The world of soap operas is filled with intriguing characters. The return of these characters is surrounded by high expectations. There could be various reasons for a comeback to be a letdown for the viewers. Sometimes, it could be a poorly written storyline, and sometimes even the recasting makes the viewers wish those characters were better when they were away.

So, in this list, let’s delve into the 10 worst comebacks in British soap history. Whether it is a lack of believable motivation or character change, these comebacks serve as cautionary tales for soap writers.

---

1)Debbie Dingle in Emmerdale

Debbie Dingle’s comeback in Emmerdale was not taken positively by the viewers. Though the viewers were excited for her return, her portrayal in the series after the comeback was not executed properly according to many viewers. Debbie was a part of Emmerdale for a long time.

Her character was part of the Dingle family. Charley Webb has portrayed her role in the series. Debbie was involved in numerous dramatic storylines in Emmerdale. From teen pregnancies to business ventures, she was an intriguing character in Emmerdale.

She has both a tough and an emotional side; hence, viewers were eager for her return. Her presence has constantly added to the show’s drama, making it an entertaining soap opera.

2)Janine Butcher in EastEnders

We know soap operas are known for their desire to build drama and chaos in the series. It adds to the overall entertainment and intrigue for the viewers. Janine’s comeback in EastEnders was a calculated chaos. However, the viewers of this long-time-running British soap opera were disappointed.

It was mainly because Janine’s arrival had an impact on Mick and Linda’s relationship. She leveraged Mick’s vulnerabilities and Linda’s struggle with alcoholism. She relied on Linda’s relapse and framed her. She became the supportive figure in Mick’s life after this.

She slowly weaved her way into his affections. Linda and Mick’s bond was created through years of hardships and shared experiences. To see their relationship crumble because of Janine did not make the viewers happy.

3)Clare Devine in Hollyoaks

Hollyoaks has been an ongoing British soap opera with its interesting plotline and compelling characters. Among these characters, Clare Devon has been receiving mixed reactions from the viewers. Her last comeback in the show was not taken positively by the viewers.

Clare was an iconic villain in the series. She used Tom’s vulnerability to manipulate him. She preyed on his emotions to get what she wanted, which was not taken well by the viewers. She had displayed a shocking level of cruelty in the series. She caused emotional distress to the characters in the series.

It was not just emotional distress but physical harm as well. She had a complete disregard for human life, which contributed to her reputation as one of the most notorious villains of Hollyoaks.

4)Jim McDonald in Coronation Street

Coronation Street has been airing since 1960. It is one of the oldest soap operas, running for decades. For any soap opera to have such a strong hold on the viewers, it needs to have all the ingredients that make a soap opera memorable. Though all the characters in Coronation Street are worthy of praise, Jim McDonald’s comeback was not as welcoming as one might expect.

His comeback was marked by a dramatic and controversial storyline. Jim was a flawed character in Coronation Street. In his latest comeback, he decided to rob a bank for the money he needed to buy The Rovers. However, his robbery turned haywire and ended up with complications. Jim’s actions had a ripple effect, causing pain and distress to the other characters of Coronation Street.

5)Kelly Windsor in Emmerdale

In Emmerdale, Kelly Windsor’s comeback had mixed reactions from the viewers. Throughout the series, her character has undergone several shifts which have been a source of constant drama. After her comeback she not only had a relationship with Scott but also had her eyes for Jimmy King. Her return has been criticized for feeling forced and lacking emotional depth.

With her manipulative nature she caused a disruption in Jimmy’s life. Jimmy lost his memory which Kelly exploited thoroughly. Her actions had a deep impact on Jimmy and Nicola’s relationship. Her motivation behind pursuing Jimmy involved a mix of opportunism and a desire to cause chaos.

6)Warren Fox in Hollyoaks

Though his most recent comeback in Hollyoaks has been a hit, his past comeback after the fire accident was not well accepted by the viewers. The recent comeback had Warren and Maxine’s relationship, which the viewers have enjoyed.

His previous comeback when he was believed to be dead because of the fire was complicated. The fire was a crucial event in Warren’s character history in Hollyoaks. Many viewers had noted that the previous comeback was disruptive in nature. It caused issues with the natural flow of the narrative. It made his presence feel less organic, according to the viewers.

7)Bet Lynch in Coronation Street

Coronation Street characters have left the shows and returned time and again. This feature makes the viewers eagerly wait for their return and have high expectations of the comebacks. In a similar manner, Bet Lynch’s comeback in Coronation Street was also filled with a lot of expectations from the viewers.

However, many viewers have pointed out that Bet Lynch’s return was underwhelming. This was because the viewers were expecting her comeback to last longer. She is an iconic character of Coronation Street; hence, the weight of expectation is immense.

8)Ben Mitchell in EastEnders

Soap operas are the titans of long-running series. As a result, many a time, characters have a change in the actors. Many characters grow up, and to properly match the character’s requirements, actors are changed. Sometimes the actors that come in place of the previous ones receive immense positive reactions from the viewers.

However, this was not the case for Ben Mitchell’s comeback in EastEnders. Joshua Roscoe played Ben Mitchell in the comeback. Many viewers have pointed out that the shift was not proper. Ben transitioned from a troubled and sympathetic childhood to an aggressive individual. Though this added depth to the character, the audience failed to resonate with the character’s comeback this time.

9)Kat Moon in EastEnders

Yet another character from EastEnders, who created quite a buzz with her comeback but left the viewers disappointed. Kat’s comeback was anticipated but fell short of expectations.

Though Jessie Wallace’s performance remained strong, the material she was given did not always resonate with the viewers after the comeback. The long-time viewers of EastEnders wanted the classic Kat to return. The build-up surrounding her comeback created a level of expectation that was hard to meet, according to many viewers.

10)Vicki Fowler EastEnders

The grown-up version of Vicki Fowler in EastEnders was not accepted by the viewers in a positive manner. Vicki is a significant character in EastEnders. The viewers had high expectations of the show’s casting; however, many have pointed out that Scarlett Johnson’s portrayal of Vicki Johnson was not accurate.

Recasting can be a hit or miss. It is crucial to cast actors that would be able to resonate with the viewers. Though Scarlett Johnson is a talented actor, many viewers have noted that her casting was disappointing. Recasting is a challenge for all soap operas. As long-running shows, it becomes essential to use other actors in place of the current ones when need be.

For more interesting pieces, stay tuned to Soap Central.