Neil visited the site of the accident at the cliff, already overflowing with flowers and mementos offered as tokens of affection for the missing Dru. A photo of Dru was perched before a large bouquet of flowers. Neil cried as he knelt down and spoke aloud to the photo of Dru, telling her about his first memory of bringing Lily home from the hospital. Neil pleaded with Dru to come back and to be safe. Neil remembered the first time he met Dru when they ran into each other in the office hallway. Neil said he couldn't imagine what his life would be without Dru, so he wouldn't accept that she could be dead. Lily, Devon, Daniel and Colleen joined Neil at the site, and Phyllis left. Devon wondered how he could lose two moms. When Lily said Dru would always be here, Neil berated her for talking as if Dru were dead.
After Neil left, Lily decided to snap photos of the memorial site with Daniel's cell-phone camera. However, when she opened the phone, she saw an image of a woman's breasts on the display screen. When she asked Daniel about it, he denied knowing how the photo got there. Daniel claimed that some fraternity guys in his class had put the photo on his camera as a prank. Later, as Lily contemplated contacting Olivia and other relatives and friends about Dru, she discovered more evidence of Daniel's visits to porn sites. Daniel tried to cover, but Lily recounted that first, his computer was flooded with porn spam, and then he had a picture a girl's naked breasts on his cell phone, and then she discovered that his secret email user name is "Studguy101." Lily looked at Daniel with astonishment and asked him what was going on.
Phyllis also came to the accident site with flowers. Neil told Phyllis that he hadn't heard anything from the search team, and he pressed Phyllis to tell him exactly what had happened. Phyllis said that she and Sharon had argued over details of the photo shoot. Neil pressed her for more information, thinking that new information could lead to a rescue. Later, Nick checked on Phyllis at the office. Phyllis said she hadn't slept the night before, and she and Nick discussed the fact that the freezing weather worked against Dru's survival. When Noah came in, Nick prepared him for a visit to see his mother by explaining that she'd be bruised, but that she'd get better. Later, Phyllis told Nick that they should postpone the wedding and the rehearsal dinner. As Phyllis continued to punish herself for the accident, Nick told her that it's not like she pushed Dru over the cliff. Phyllis lamented the fact that everyone seems to feel that in a way, she had.
Sharon awoke to find Brad at her bedside at the hospital. As they were discussing Phyllis' role in the accident, Sharon mentioned the fact the Phyllis had saved her life. Jack walked in and was surprised to see Brad comforting Sharon. Sharon told Jack that if she hadn't argued with Phyllis then Dru would still be there. Jack assured Sharon that if anyone could make it, it would surely be Drucilla. When Nick brought Noah in, Jack left. Noah gave his mom the comic book he'd made that featured Sharon as the invincible blonde avenger. After Nick sent Noah to get water for Sharon's flowers, Nick and Sharon discussed the fact that Noah would have to be told about Dru. Later, Nick took Noah to the coffeehouse and gently broke the news that Dru is missing. Noah wanted to help look for Dru, but Nick explained that many people were already searching for her.
Back at the office, Brad ran into Phyllis in the break room. He told her, sarcastically, that she looked great, but that she should because she didn't suffer any injuries to cause bruising like Sharon did. The two argued about the accident, and Brad told Phyllis that by showing up at work, she had no soul, conscience or mechanism in her warped brain to determine what's appropriate. Brad accused Phyllis of manslaughter, but Phyllis reminded Brad that if he'd not had an affair, the circumstances would never have ended up as they did. She added that everyone is guilty of one thing or another. Just as Brad was berating Phyllis for being as good as guilty of pushing Sharon off the cliff, Jack walked in. As Phyllis became more upset, Jack comforted her.
Later, Jack and Brad discussed preparation of a press release about the tragedy. However, David Chow came in and handed over a press release he had already ordered a campaign staff member to write. David later told Jack that although he hated to admit it, something good could come out of the tragedy because Sharon's accident could garner sympathy votes. Jack agreed that it could, as sick as that type of thing is. David explained that the timing of the accident's not bad because Nikki has been gaining endorsements. David told Jack that the Madison newspaper wished to interview Sharon. However, Brad felt that Jack was exploiting Sharon, so Brad felt he should act to protect one of his closest friends. However, Jack reminded Brad that they were talking about his fiancé.
When Neil visited Sharon at the hospital, she told him that Phyllis was involved with the accident because she was blackmailing Sharon and Brad over their affair. Sharon explained that when they were at the photo shoot, Phyllis threatened to call Jack and tell him about Sharon's affair, and that was why they were arguing. Neil realized that Dru became involved when she stepped in to help Sharon. Neil was shocked when Sharon told him that Phyllis forced Brad to give him the seat on the board in order to keep Phyllis from disclosing Brad and Sharon's affair. After Neil left, Brad returned and Sharon told him that Neil knew the whole story of Phyllis' blackmail. Brad wondered if Neil would talk about the affair. An exhausted Sharon apologized saying that she was sorry that circumstances turned out the way they did. Brad offered Sharon comfort just as Jack returned. Jack remarked to Sharon, somewhat sarcastically, that it looked as if she was in good hands.
After Neil's revealing visit with Sharon, he confronted Phyllis and warned her that he'd hold her personally responsible if his wife didn't make it. As Jack gently urged Neil to back off and take it easy, he exclaimed that Dru's blood would be on Phyllis' hands.