Victor doesn't understand what Abby means when she tells him she saw a video of her mom telling her that Victor is her father. Abby tells Victor that she would like to go find Colleen. Victor says goodbye and goes to the Athletic Club to find Brad. Victor tells Brad that Abby told him something that he came to find out about. Abby told him she saw a videotape of her mommy saying that Victor is Abby's real father. Victor wonders if this information has upset Brad in some way. Brad says that it upsets him for only one reason. It's the truth. Victor still doesn't understand how Abby could be his daughter. He and Ashley had not had an affair and with his vasectomy it would be virtually impossible for Abby to be Victor's. Brad tries not to get into details but he tells Victor that Ashley's pregnancy involved a sperm bank and artificial insemination. Victor wonders why Ashley would have done this to him. He remembers the day he held Abby in his arms and how the nurse had thought he was the father. He remembers Ashley's strange reaction. Brad asks Victor that he let Ashley tell him at the ranch. Victor says he doesn't want to talk to Ashley right now. All this time he has had a daughter and Ashley has kept this from him. He wants to think about what he will do. Brad says that this doesn't change anything, but Victor disagrees. It changes everything.
Katherine is getting ready to go to the Colonnade room with Arthur. Arthur comes downstairs with a box and tells Katherine that she looks beautiful. When Katherine asks Arthur what's in the box, Arthur says some toys. Katherine says there haven't been children in the house in many years. Arthur says they are not those kinds of toys. They are adult toys. Katherine is surprised. They do not belong to Katherine; she has never seen them in her life. As Arthur wonders whom they could possibly belong to, Jill walks in. She tells Arthur that she's had a rough day at Jabot and would like to take him out to dinner so they can talk. Arthur tells Jill that he and Katherine have already made plans to go to the Colonnade room. Jill asks that they go out some other time. Katherine gets upset and Arthur asks that they all go to dinner together. Katherine and Jill begin arguing. Neither wants to go with each other. Arthur says fine, they will all stay at home and he will cook a nice dinner for them. As Arthur goes to the kitchen to start cooking, Katherine tells Jill that she is being selfish and wants Arthur all to herself. "What if I do?" Jill yells. Arthur intervenes again and warns Katherine and Jill that they better not mess with a judge. He could have them confined to their rooms.
As Lauren is locking the door to the Boutique, Michael opens it and scares Lauren. Michael can tell that Kevin must have been there. Lauren says that if she tells Michael something will he be forced to go to the authorities. When Michael asks her to tell him, Lauren tells Michael about Kevin's confession. Michael is saddened that his own brother didn't tell him. Lauren asks Michael what she should do. Michael says it would be wise if she went to the authorities. That's what Paul told her too. Michael is shocked at this information. Now it will all be over for Kevin. Michael thinks Paul is probably down at the station right now. He asks Lauren to try to get Paul to back off. He leaves to go see Kevin.
Paul shows up at Michael's house and pushes the door open when Kevin answers. Paul tells Kevin that Lauren told him about his confession. Kevin is shocked but says that he didn't tell Lauren anything. Paul says it would be in Kevin's best judgment to turn himself in. Kevin tells Paul he still has no real evidence against him and he should just give the whole thing up. As Paul leaves, he says that if Kevin really cares about Lauren, he would do this for her. Kevin packs a bag and writes Michael a letter. He thinks about having a brother and some hope and that it was great while it lasted. He leaves.
Brad comes home and is surprised to find Ashley there. When she says that she agreed to let Nikki be the one to tell Victor about Abby, Brad doesn't seem too happy and Ashley wonders why. Brad tells her that things are quickly spinning out of control.
Nikki is waiting for Victor to return home when Ashley calls. Nikki says Victor still hasn't shown up and please leave her alone. She hangs up and thinks about her and Ashley's conversation about Victor's love for her. Victor comes in and asks Nikki where Ashley is. Nikki tells him she must talk to him. Victor says he doesn't want to talk about anything right now. Nikki says she must tell him something. This thing Ashley was going to tell him has been put in her hands now.