Jill asked Nikki what the surprise was, and Nikki told her that Kay's physical therapy was going great, and that she was starting to be able to use her hands. Larry's reaction was quick and positive, but Jill looked a bit uncomfortable. Nikki pointedly stated how great it was to Jill, and she tried to recover, but her initial reaction did not go unnoticed. She tried to tell everybody that they shouldn't push and stress Kay out, but no one really listened. They all marveled at how Kay was using a fork, and excitedly talking about what new progress she might be making in just a few short weeks if the momentum kept up.
At that point, Jill excused herself to go powder her nose, and Larry got up as well. Jill was upset, and told Larry that just because she could use her hand doesn't mean she can take care of herself. Back at the table, Nikki told Esther Kay had a test in mind for Jill to see if she was sincere. As they started to discuss it, Brock and Mitchell Sherman walked in, and Gina brought them over to the table. Jill was startled to see them once she returned and asked what they were doing there. They explained they had a meeting and decided to conduct it over dinner. Nikki piped up and told Jill she invited them to join the group. Jill sat next to Kay this time, and started fussing over her; trying to put a napkin in her lap and adjust her chair. Esther tried to take over and Kay "accidentally" spilled her water in Jill's lap.
The conversation turned to Jill's idea of declaring Kay incompetent, and Nikki got infuriated. Jill tried to explain her point of view, that she was only concerned about Kay's well-being and financials, but said she would just drop it if no one else agreed. Brock offered that he gave her the benefit of the doubt when it came to her sincerity, but that he didn't at all agree they should have her declared incompetent.
Paul came back from California to find Michael in their living room. Before he was able to check on Chris, Michael pulled him aside and updated him on the situation. He told Paul he didn't think any of the evidence they gathered would be admissible in court, considering the police interrupted a doctor/patient visit. Paul asked if the hypnosis worked, but Michael didn't have a solid answer for him. What he did say was that it was extremely difficult to defend a client that thought they were guilty, and he felt Chris did not believe she was innocent. Meanwhile, Chris was in the bedroom, hearing voices and seeing visions of Isabella screaming.
Michael left and Paul checked on Chris, who was quite upset. He tried to convince her she was innocent, but she had strong doubts. They were interrupted by Detective Weber, who said he had news. He said the lab results that came back proved that the DNA under her fingernails was that of Isabella's. Paul questioned him immediately, but Weber had more news. He said they found traces of blood in the woods, in a way that appeared a body was dragged. While Paul tried to come up with ulterior possibilities, Chris just cried and cried.
Lily was feeling very uncomfortable in Kevin's apartment. She told him she was so afraid that he never wanted to see her again, and that she wasn't used to someone liking her as much as she liked them. He told her how much he liked her and how beautiful she was---and to finish her glass of champagne. He went on to say how he felt Colleen treated him like a monster and told her he would never do anything to hurt her. He strongly hinted at the fact that she should dump Colleen if being with him started to create even more of an issue than it already had. With that, he started kissing her forcefully, which made her uncomfortable. She tried to pull away, telling him he was going too fast. Ignoring her, he took off his shirt and began to unbutton hers when there was a knock on the door. It was Colleen and J.T., calling out for Lily. This infuriated Kevin, and he got dressed and started to panic. He opened the door and J.T. asked him what took so long. Lily was mortified and told them they were worse than her parents, and how much they were embarrassing her. Colleen told her she thought she should leave with them and J.T. agreed. Colleen looked down and saw the champagne and when J.T. saw it, he snapped. He asked if Kevin was trying to get her drunk, told him she was only 15 and punched him for the offense. Kevin started screaming for everyone to get out, including Lily, because the evening was ruined. Lily ran out, and before the others turned to leave, J.T. threatened Kevin to stay away from all of them.