After hearing Vanessa's screams, everyone went to Vanessa's aid. They all seen Jade's body and went back to the house. Everyone tried to stay calm, but then Amy brought up that maybe the killer is among them...
Cole found out from the bartender where Caitlin was headed. As he was about to go, Ricardo stopped him and asked him once again if he knew where Jade was. Coel said no, and Ricardo warned him, for Paula and Elaine's sake, do not go back to his old ways.
Caitlin confessed to Annie that she lost the baby in the accident and can no longer have children. Annie and Caitlin went to a coffee shop. Coel showed up and asked a homeless person if he had seen Caitlin...a blond pregnant girl. The old man said yes, but that she surely didn't look pregnant, in fact she had a nice figure. He also told Cole she was with a red headed woman.
Caitlin and Annie discussed Caitlin's options. Caitlin showed her her pregnancy pillow and told her how she has deceived Cole. Annie kept thinking that this is good to have Caitlin in her corner. Cole shows up and spots Caitlin....
After Tim found the bloody fishhook in Mark's bag, Tim suspected that Mark was the killer. Mark ran out of the house to find the real killer. Casey and Michael went after him. Looking for food in the kitchen, Sean found Jade's purse, which contained priceless jewels, and his credit card. All the lights went out in the house...downstairs, Virginia heard a voice, she seen that Mark's camera had recorded something from on the boat, it was Elizabeth, she thought nothing of it. The killer came in and grabbed the fishhook, and stepped up behind Virginia. Michael and Casey returned without Mark and the killer hid. Upstairs, Meg, Gabi and Vanessa searched for blankets for them all to sleep downstairs. Michael found them and they all went downstairs. Sean showed them what was in Jade's purse, Meg concluded that Jade stole her ring, not found it. Michael and Casey went back out to search for Mark, Vanessa and Meg went as well, without anyone knowing. Tim, Sean, Vanessa, Gabi and Amy stayed behind. Amy found Mark's camera, as they all watched the videotape, they seen the masked person attacking Elizabeth. Vanessa's light went out, so she went back to the house, Meg was about to go behind her when she heard some noise, she called out Mark's name, unbeknownst to her, the masked person was watching her...
Annie spilled soda on Caitlin so that Caitlin could go to the bathroom without Cole noticing she didn't have her pregnancy pillow in. Cole asked Annie what they were talking about, Annie lied saying that Caitlin asked her to be in her wedding party. In the bathroom, Caitlin practiced telling Cole the truth, as she is tired of lying. Annie told her that after talking to Cole, maybe it isn't best to tell him, she may lose him. While Cole went to get the car, Caitlin told Annie that she is glad to have her on her side, and can't wait to see how Annie will find a baby for her. Annie wonders how she is going to get a baby, Caitlin is really counting on her, and she can't let her down...she needs Caitlin's support for her inheritance.
Gregory gives Eddie an assignment, and tries to get him to watch Olivia while he's at Bette's, but Eddie refuses too. Bette waltzes in and told Gregory that the only way he will win Olivia back is if he backs off a bit...