Edna and Norma use Spike as their slave. If he doesn't do what he is told, Tabitha will send him to the basement. At the Bennett's household, Simone can't believe that she has a murderer for a brother. Sam gets prepared to arrest Jessica for the dead johns, but Kay uses magic to try to save Jessica. She freezes Sam and everyone else and decides to go to Tabitha for help. Instead of walking over to Tabitha's house for her assistance, she zaps herself over there, but Sam, Paloma, Jessica, and Noah are also with her. Sam wonders how they got to Tabitha's house. Tabitha keeps warning Kay not to use her powers until she is properly trained. She now has to cast a spell to reverse what Kay has done, so that they won't get suspicious. Kay makes another attempt to prove that Jessica is innocent. She cast a spell on Spike so that he would confess, but her spell backfires. Spike confesses, but Noah, Paloma, Simone, and also Sam confess to the murder of the johns as well. Kay can't seem to get her spells to work in her favor. After disobeying Tabitha, Kay zaps Sam and the others back to her house. She thinks her magic has saved the day because Sam decides not to arrest Jessica. He arrests Kay instead stating that all the evidence points to her.
Sheridan pushes an unwilling Pretty to tell Luis about what Fancy did to her. Meanwhile, Luis and Fancy are making up for lost times by spending some quality time with each other. Fancy remembers the incident with Pretty while with Luis and is affected by it. She promises herself that she can never let Luis know the truth. Meanwhile, Pretty and Sheridan are upstairs looking for Luis and Fancy. Sheridan doesn't want Pretty to get sidetracked, so she keeps reminding Pretty that Fancy was Alistair's favorite. Both Pretty and Fancy have fond memories of each other, but Pretty's scar have torn them apart. While Sheridan leaves to meet her visitor at the cottage, Pretty goes off in search of Luis and Fancy. Chris is back in Harmony to discuss James with Sheridan. He tells Sheridan that James is having a hard time dealing with the separation. Sheridan apologizes to Chris. She insists to Chris that she wants to see James, but Chris tells her that James needs to adjust to the separation first. Sheridan seems to understand the situation. While feeling sorry about what she did to James, Sheridan tells a mystery visitor that she cannot see him/her right now. Back at the mansion, Fancy awakens from a nightmare about Pretty telling Luis the truth about the scar on her face. She turns to Luis to tell him about the nightmare, and Pretty walks up on her and tells her that it's time to turn her nightmare into a reality.
Theresa and Ethan are planning to elope, and Gwen walks in on them in a compromising position. She apologizes for barging in and tells Ethan that Little Ethan is asking about him. Theresa is suspicious of Gwen and asks what she is up to. In addition, Theresa tells Gwen that she will tell Ethan the truth when it's convenient to her, and they will work it out, and they will be very happy. Gwen tells Theresa that she is incapable of making anyone happy. All she will cause is misery. Ethan walks in on Gwen telling Theresa that he is Little Ethan's (LE) father, and Ethan asks her to repeat herself, but Gwen plays it off and states that he is like a father to LE. Against Theresa's wishes, Ethan tells Gwen that they are eloping.