Chad can't be talked out of wanting to be with Whitney. Even though Father Lonigan warns him that it is a sin, he wants to be a part of her life. Eve and Julian are disgusted with the thought of Eve's son and daughter actually wanting to spend their lives together. Chad goes too far when he offers to help raise Whitney's baby, and Fox is angry and in disbelief. Ivy tells Fox that he needs to be prepared for the possibility that Whitney might accept Chad's proposal. When Chad asks Whitney if she wants to be with him, Eve intervenes and says she won't let Whitney do this, and Whitney can't take the risk of having a second baby with her own brother.
The plane is nowhere to be found, but the good news is there have been no signs of any explosions. Sam says there must be some sort of device on the plane to keep it from appearing on the radars. Ethan takes Theresa back to her house, and Rebecca is not happy that when Gwen has disappeared on a plane, Ethan is spending his time with Theresa. Pilar enjoys Martin's pain in losing Katherine and refuses to give him a divorce, saying that he needs to reconcile with his family and she needs to try to forgive him for abandoning them. Sheridan prays for her mother's return and confides in Father Lonigan, telling him that she knows her child is still alive. When he tells her that her baby died and offers to call Luis, she runs out of the church. Father Lonigan calls Luis and tells him he is concerned about Sheridan and that he doesn't know where she went.
Beth decides that she will go ahead with her plan to murder Sheridan and make it look like a suicide, except this time Sheridan will die at Beth's house-so when Sheridan comes to Beth on the verge of a breakdown and asks to stay there, Beth is more than happy to agree.
On the waterfront, Pilar and Luis talked about Sheridan. Luis was worried that she'd harm herself. He can't find her and he's upset that she's so angry. Pilar doesn't think it's time to worry. Luis started to realize that he is to blame for her anger. Pilar told him that he might be smothering Sheridan instead of protecting her. Pilar reminded him of the lesson Father Lonigan told Precious at the wedding about letting love go. Pilar told him that she's trying to forgive Martin and that Luis needs to forgive Katherine. He listed all the reasons why he shouldn't. He thought there are some things that are unforgivable. Luis still didn't want anything to do with his father. Pilar reminded him that you have to love when it's really hard. Luis listed all the ways their lives would be different if Martin hadn't left and Pilar reminded him that if Martin hadn't left, Luis would be married to Beth with several kids and he would never have met or fallen in love with Sheridan.
At the Wallace house, Sheridan thanked Beth for letting her stay there. Beth said that's what friends are for and Edna thought that with friends like Beth, enemies need not apply. Edna suggested she go home to Luis and Sheridan said she couldn't because they'd had a big fight. Beth planned to kill Sheridan in the night. Beth asked if Sheridan wants some tea and when Sheridan balked, didn't push it. Beth asked what the fight was about and Sheridan explained all the points. Beth acted sympathetic. Edna blurted out that Beth would kill her with kindness. Sheridan asked for advice. Beth asked her if she loved him and Sheridan waxed poetic about their love. Beth started driving wedges between Sheridan and Luis by telling her that she had the right to tell Luis he could never see Pilar again if he was going to insist she never see her mother again. Beth told her that bond between mother and child was strong (and then Edna imagined Beth hooked up to a lie detector being questioned by Sheridan. It blew up when Sheridan asked her if she was a psychopath trying to kill her.) Beth told Sheridan there was only one answer to this problem. She could never see Luis again. Sheridan told her she could never not see Luis. Sheridan told her that she still wanted Marty in her life and that she couldn't stop thinking he was her little boy. She asked Bath for forgiveness. Sheridan started to call Luis and a quaking Beth insisted she couldn't. Beth stammered that she should get a good night's sleep first. Sheridan agreed and Beth told her to get settled in the guest room and she'd bring her some tea. Beth planned out how she would give Sheridan the sleeping pill overdose, they'd wake up in the morning, go into the guest room, and find Sheridan and her suicide note. Then she had Edna and Precious practice looking shocked.
While Ivy made coffee for Tabitha at the Bennett house, Fox and Ivy marveled that Chad still wants to be with Whitney. Ivy remarked that "this whole thing has Larry Winger written all over it." Fox thought he could just go outside and propose to Whitney again and everything would be all right. Meanwhile, outside Tabitha looked on while Eve stuck her foot in her mouth as she told Whitney that she'd put herself at risk for having a second baby with her own half-brother. Whitney and Julian stopped her before she dug her hole too deep, but Chad asked if she meant he was the father of Whitney's baby. Ivy and Fox noticed the commotion and raced outside to find out what was going on. Chad repeated what Eve said. Ivy dropped the coffee tray, causing Tabitha to complain that she was really looking forward to that cup of coffee so Endora zapped one up for her. Eve managed to cover for herself. Fox told Chad to stop saying he wanted to be with Whitney. Julian tried to convince Chad that it would be wrong to live with Whitney. Eve tried to convince Whitney to just be with Fox. Fox asked Whitney all over again to marry him. He told her all the reasons why he loves her. Whitney told him she couldn't marry him.
At the club, Jessica and Paloma are high and Randy takes Jessica to a back room, where he gives her another "sticker" to lick and gets ready to take advantage of her. Kay and Simone find the club and stumble across Paloma, but can't find Jessica. They decide she's probably already left, so they take Paloma and go home.
Pilar tries to make Luis believe that he actually should be grateful to Martin, because if Martin hadn't left Luis would never have fallen in love with Sheridan. Pilar says she is disappointed he cannot come to terms with his father leaving, and calls it a test of faith. She tells him God knows what is best for them and the path to happiness is forgiveness. Luis refuses to forgive his father for abandoning them. Luis leaves to go and look for Sheridan at the café, while Pilar goes to see Theresa.
Theresa is waiting with Ethan for an update at the Lopez-Fitzgerald house, but there is still no news on the plane's whereabouts. Pilar comes to check up on them and tells Little Ethan, who has woken up again, that his little sister is on an "exciting plane ride." Ethan thinks he should go home for the night, but Little Ethan asks him to stay and asks Theresa and Ethan to put him to sleep. Ethan hesitates, but Theresa, Ethan and Little Ethan end up falling asleep together.
Beth drugs another cup of tea, but Sheridan politely declines when Beth offers it to her, saying that tea keeps her up at night. Sheridan goes upstairs to go to bed, and Beth comes up with another plan. She calls Luis and says that Sheridan is at her house, but she doesn't think he should come over because Sheridan said she doesn't want to see or speak to Luis. Beth tells Luis to stay where he is and she'll come there to talk about Sheridan. When Beth leaves, Mrs. Wallace brings Marty to Sheridan's room and says Marty can spend the night with Sheridan. At the café, Beth says that Sheridan was adamant she didn't want to see him and she is furious with him. She convinces him that if he were to go try to talk to her, it would make things worse and tells him if Sheridan knows how he feels about Katherine and wants to have a relationship with her anyway, Beth thinks it means she has already told him that her mother is more important than him.
At the Harmony police department, Martin and Sam checked out airports on the computer to see if the Crane jet has landed. It appears that with Crane money the jet and its occupants might land anywhere without detection or that the landing could be covered up by Alistair. Martin lamented the loss of his love-Katherine and Pilar walked in just in time to hear him rant about her leaving without any way for him to find her. Pilar told him that now he'll know how it feels. Pilar begged Martin to tell why he left. She had come because she couldn't sleep, went for a walk, and saw Sam working through the window. A cop walked by and told Martin he hoped he found his wife. Pilar took exception to that, reminding him that she is his wife. Pilar begged him again to tell her why he left. He said it was worse than she could imagine. Sam told him that he should tell, especially if there was information that could help him convict Alistair of a crime. As Pilar left, Sam and Martin were talking about Sam's marital history and how he's back with his first love. Martin told him he was lucky. It appeared that Sam could see that Pilar was still within earshot when he asked Martin if he wanted to be back with his first love. He never directly answered, but danced all around the issue. When they discussed their troubles with their kids, Martin told Sam how proud he was of his kids and how much he admired the way Pilar had raised them. Sam told him that Miguel sends regular checks home to take care of baby Maria. Sam told Martin how worried he is about Jessica's wild ways. He said the only reason she's at home is because he grounded her.
At the club, Randy was admonished by the sex room gatekeeper to hurry up and finish. Randy handed him some more money and when a drugged Jessica told him she didn't want any more sex because she didn't feel good, he had her lick one of the drug stickers. After being yelled at by the gatekeeper again, Randy played a live version of "dress the Barbie." He led Jessica out to the main club and sat her in a chair so he could make eyes at more chicks. When he got back to the chair, Jessica had wandered out the door and vanished from his sight. Jessica bumped into a couple of young women entering the club and one of them commented that she looked like she was suffering from "sticker shock." She wandered the streets toward home and bumped her head on a telephone pole, knocking her to the ground. She opened her eyes and shielded them just as a car, driven by a man under the influence, careened her way.
At the Bennett house, Kay and Simone tended to a drugged out Paloma and wrung their hands, worrying about where Jessica could possibly be. They bemoaned their mothers' less than admirable job and postulated that it would be good to have grandmothers. While visualizing the perfect grandmother, Kay had a Charity-like vision of Jessica lying on the ground with blood on her face. Simone bemoaned Liz trying to step in to be her mother and realized her dad didn't know about the circus going on in the yard below, so she called him and told him he needed to come to the Bennett's because Whitney was having problems. She told him about Fox and Chad's proposals and T.C. swore he'd kill Chad. Simone told him to stay home if he was going to be violent. He and Liz hurried right over to see what the matter was. Fox whined to Ivy about why Whitney turned him down. Eve moaned to Julian about Whitney and Chad said it was because she loved him that she wouldn't marry Fox. Julian tried to talk sense into him. Fox and Chad started arguing and Whitney broke them up. When T.C. arrived, he berated Eve for not involving him. Liz immediately asked Whitney to sit down and discuss things rationally. T.C asked what was going on and Chad said that he loved Whitney and they were going to be together. T.C. and Chad got into a knock down fight, but Julian and Fox pulled them apart before any real damage. Tabitha was disappointed about the lack of blood, so Endora made each of their noses bleed. T.C. then went off on the Cranes for ruining his wife and daughter and all the women with whom they had relationships. Fox and Chad each made their claims for Whitney and she decreed that she'd never get married to anyone.
While tending to Paloma, Kay is frightened by a disturbing vision of Jessica. As her sister worries, a dazed Jessica roams the streets, getting herself into even more trouble.
Whitney stuns everyone when she announces she turned down Fox's proposal because she never wants to get married! Explaining that every marriage in Harmony has ended in disaster, Whitney declares she's going to raise her child by herself.
As a distraught Sheridan settles into bed at Beth's, she tries to convince herself that Marty is not her child. Meanwhile, Beth meets with Luis and attempts to convince him that Sheridan wants nothing to do with him.
Pilar is affected when she overhears Martin telling Sam how hard it was to leave and that he never stopped loving his wife. Sam encourages Martin to reveal his secret to his family, but a pained Martin insists it will destroy them to know the truth. Pilar stops eavesdropping and confronts her husband.