Charity and Miguel can't believe the bad luck omens that keep following them. When they returned home from the wedding reception they walk into the Bennett house and step on a mirror. Charity sees it as 7 years bad luck. When they go up to Charity's room a black cat crosses their path. As they step into Charity's bedroom they walk under a ladder that was place in the doorway.
David accompanies Grace home. Grace questions Charity about the omens and then turns on Kay. She asks Kay if she is behind them. Kay says that she is but she is not guilty. Kay says that the black cat came through an open window. A window that Grace left open. She then explains that the cat knocked over a mirror and then ran into Charity's room. Kay got the ladder to get the cat down before she could ruin Charity's wedding dress. Charity buys the story but Grace does not. Grace corners Kay and warns her not to try anything at the wedding tomorrow. Kay tells her mother she will do what she pleases and there is not a damn thing she can do about it. Kay then sees David go into her mother's bedroom.
The sounds of a terrified Theresa screaming rattles everyone in the Crane mansion. Gwen begs Ethan not to leave her to find out what Theresa is screaming about. Gwen is sure that it is just another plan to keep the newlyweds apart.
Ivy and Sam hear the screaming as does Julian and Rebecca. Ethan is the first on the scene and attacks Theresa's intruder. They begin to beat each other up. Sam tries to break in on the fight. The door is locked and as he keeps hearing Theresa scream, he has no choice but to break the door down. Sam breaks up the fight. The intruder is identified as Foxworth Crane. He smiles smugly and says, "I'm Back." He introduces himself to Theresa as the now oldest son of Ivy and Julian since Ethan is no longer a Crane. No one in the family seem particularly happy to see Fox. Julian and Ivy both feel that there is big trouble on the way.
Eve comes home to find Liz working on her plan to get TC. Liz entices TC into a sexy dance with her. Eve asks rather angrily what is going on. TC explains how innocent the dance was. It was innocent to TC but Eve knows what Liz is up to. Liz again tells Eve she is going to ruin her life.
Tabitha tries out the size of her casket. She is sure that after Miguel and Charity's wedding tomorrow she will be dead. Cracked Connie and Cecil have other ideas. They begin to loot Tabitha's house of all her antiques. They plan on getting as much as they can get their money grubbing hands on and hitting the open road.
Sam arrives home and grabs champagne to mend fences with Grace. Kay acts upset and purposely tries to get her father not to go upstairs, knowing that he would want to all the more. He walks into Grace's bedroom to find that she fell asleep in David's arms. Kay smiles to herself that "Payback is a bitch."
Ethan takes Fox aside and warns him to stay the hell away from Theresa. Fox questions Ethan why he should care if he spends time with Theresa, who he affectionately calls "stepmommie." Fox reminds his half-brother that he is now a married man.
Gwen gets catty with Theresa and asks if her nerves have calmed down enough for her and Ethan to continue their honeymoon. Theresa puts Gwen in her place by reminding her that Ethan left Gwen's honeymoon bed to come to her rescue. She tells Gwen that it certainly shows who is locked in Ethan's heart. Gwen just scowls at Theresa.
Tabitha emerges from her coffin just in time to prevent Connie and Cecil from stealing everything that isn't nailed down. Whitney is alarmed to realize that she's overslept and spent the entire night in Chad's arms. Meanwhile, back at the Russell domicile, Liz thinks fast to keep T.C. from discovering that his elder daughter never came home the night before. Fox makes himself right at home, much to the annoyance of the others in residence at the Crane mansion. Unnerved to awaken next to David, Grace hopes Sam won't get wind of her latest indiscretion. A sullen Kay prepares to face defeat. Theresa enjoys watching Ethan's reaction when she reveals that Fox will be escorting her to Miguel's wedding. Whitney thanks Liz for her cover story. Gwen asks a startled Ethan if he's still in love with Theresa. After Sam catches David trying to sneak out of the house, Grace shakily insists nothing happened between her and her first husband. Later, as the wedding begins, Kay collapses before Miguel and Charity can exchange vows.
Tabitha faces her friends in the basement. Later, she tries to lure Cecil and Cracked Connie to the basement.
David fills Ivy in on what happened last night with Grace. Ivy is thrilled and is certain she will have Sam in no time. David continues to feel guilty. Ivy thinks he should be thanking her for helping him get Grace.
Kay faints in the middle of Charity and Miguel's wedding. Grace believes Kay is faking it. Eve informs an alarmed crowd that something is truly wrong with Kay. Grace wonders if her daughter made herself faint. Eve runs an important test on Kay.
At the wedding, Theresa and Fox bond. Ethan is not happy with his mischievous brother being near Theresa. Fox and Ethan exchange words. Gwen continues to question Ethan about his true feelings. Theresa is pleased with how things are going. Antonio and Beth both have worries about their own upcoming weddings.
Theresa spends part of the Christmas holiday at the Crane Mansion. She gives Ethan and expensive lap top as a gift from his godson, Little Ethan. Ethan graciously accepts and then has a small gift for Theresa. Gwen watches jealously as Rebecca reminds her that she is Ethan's wife, not Theresa.
Fox drops a bombshell on his family. He plans on staying in Harmony permanently. He says he wants to work at Crane Industries and wants Theresa to be his mentor.
Theresa takes her family to an undisclosed location. She is very mysterious about where they are going. Theresa ushers everyone into a beautiful new house. She announces that this is the new, rebuilt Lopez-Fitzgerald home. Pilar right away says she can't accept the gift because it was built with Crane money. Theresa explains that all their family and friends helped to rebuild the house. She explains that everyone pitched in and would be hurt if the gift was not accepted. Pilar agrees as Theresa takes everyone on a tour. She even offers a room to Luis and Beth when they become newlyweds.
Tabitha comes to spend the day with the Bennetts. Everyone is putting their problems and worries aside for the holiday. Tabby asks Kay why she did not use protection. Kay defends her actions and can't help showing her happiness over her pregnancy. The Bennetts give Tabitha a very special Christmas present. They present her with a scrapbook of Timmy's life. Tabby tearfully pours over the pictures and seems truly grateful for the gift.
Once Tabitha goes home she spies the elusive baby that she has been chasing for the past several weeks. She almost has the baby cornered when it jumps into Tabitha's belly. Tabitha orders him to come out. She then flashes back to her wild night with Julian Crane. She realizes that the baby belongs to her. Tabitha puts a hand to her stomach and faints dead away!
The day after Christmas finds the families of Harmony facing up to their problems. At the new Lopez-Fitzgerald home the family is having a meeting about Miguel's situation and what he should do about it. Pilar feels that Miguel should do the "right thing" by Kay and marry her. Theresa jumps in and tells Miguel that he should marry his true love, not marry out of obligation. Pilar gets angry and asks Theresa how she could use her past situation with Ethan to cloud Miguel's choice.
Beth and her mother get into a heated argument as Beth begins to pack for her honeymoon. Beth tells her mother that she hired a private nurse to look after her while she is gone. Mrs. Wallace tells Beth that she cancelled the nurse because Beth will not be going on a honeymoon and not marrying Luis.
Mrs. Wallace screams this for the last time in Beth's face. Beth says to herself that there is no need for a nurse because she is going to kill her mother.
Hank arrives at the Lopez-Fitzgerald home and warns Miguel to stay away from Sam. Hank says that his brother will kill him if he lays eyes on him. Pilar begs Miguel to reconsider his decision not to marry Kay.
At the Bennett home Sam goes off on how Miguel seduced Kay. Grace defends Miguel and says that Kay probably manipulated the whole thing. She says she feels that Kay is helping evil in Harmony and in their lives. Sam can't believe that Grace could think so lowly of their daughter. David comes in and agrees with Grace as does John. Sam tells the two they have no place to voice their opinions since they are not family. Grace jumps in and says that they are family and Kay is David's stepdaughter. Sam says the hell she is. Sam blames David and John for taking Grace away from Kay. Sam says that the three of them helped cause all of this.
Sheridan frantically calls Gwen for support. As her wedding day draws closer she is getting cold feet. Sheridan explains to Gwen that she just can't go through with marrying Antonio when she truly loves Luis. Gwen puts the idea in Sheridan's head that Beth may not be so sweet and understanding as she appears. Sheridan quickly defends Beth by telling Gwen that Beth does not have a mean bone in her body. While Sheridan is telling Gwen of Beth's virtues, Beth is attacking her mother with a letter opener. Mrs. Wallace is saved by the bell. The phone rings and stops Beth from doing her mother in. Beth calms down when she hears the private nurse on the other end. She once again has someone to take care of her mother and tells Mrs. Wallace she is off the hook for now. Mrs. Wallace tells her daughter she is not worried because she knows the wedding will not come off. She reminds Beth how disastrous all the Harmony weddings are.
Eve arrives at Sheridan's cottage. Eve tells Sheridan that even though Antonio's condition is very serious, she should follow her heart and not marry him when she does not love him. Eve reminds Sheridan that if Antonio knew the truth, he would not want her to marry him out of obligation or pity. Sheridan tells Gwen and Eve she must be alone to think and make a decision.
Charity asks Kay how it "happened" with Miguel. Kay lies and tells her cousin that it happened after the zombie broke up with Miguel. She says that all of Charity's premonitions helped make it happen. Simone tells Kay that she is a piece of work by actually having Charity shoulder some of the blame for the pregnancy. Miguel shows up at the Bennett house and Sam goes ballistic. He grabs Miguel by the throat.
Sheridan sneaks into Luis' shower and tells him she loves him. She says she has come back to him forever. They kiss.