In the opening scene, Scotty calls Serena from jail to wish her a happy Thanksgiving. Lucy was not there to receive the call. She was visiting Kevin at the Lighthouse. They were sharing a special moment when Eve arrived. Lucy made a hasty exit. Eve's plan is to rescue Kevin and Victor from spending Thanksgiving alone. She wants everyone to put all of the bad memories behind and think about the good things. Eve has made arrangements for the three of them to go to a Karaoke bar and grill.
At the firehouse, Serena is sad because her father is in jail. Lee tries to cheer her up by telling her a story about the time when Scotty brought home a stray dog and hid the dog for weeks without him knowing about it. Lee was allergic to dogs and could not understand why he was sneezing all of the time. Then on Thanksgiving, Scotty ran into the dining room white as a ghost. Lee went into the kitchen to see what was the matter and found the dog with the turkey hanging out of his mouth. Lee's only reply was, "Get that dog some gravy!" After the laughter was through, Serena wanted to call her dad. Lucy had a better idea. She decided to bring Thanksgiving dinner to Scotty.
The Karaoke threesome enter the bar and grill and ordered a huge beverage in a coconut with three straws.
Scotty was surprised when he entered the interrogation room to find all of his family there with Thanksgiving dinner. Garcia enters the room and is invited to share Thanksgiving dinner with the family.
At the Karaoke bar, Kevin persuades Eve to sing. She agrees only if Kevin sings with her. The twosome sing "Don't go breaking my heart" off key! After the song, Eve and Kevin convince Victor to sing. Victor performs "I'm to sexy for my shirt". Kevin thanks Eve for making this Thanksgiving a most memorable occasion.
At the jail, Karen and Joe make their departure. Lee talks about Julie's case. They all agree that Julie would not have done what she did if she had not been brainwashed by Cooper. Garcia enters with somewhat distressing news, "My men just reported from Jasmine Island. Cooper is presumed dead, however no body was found!"