Julie is having a nightmare. She sees herself as a teenager searching for her brother. Greg Cooper is in the dream along with her father and Frank. The dream makes her doubt Frank's innocence.
For the Halloween party, the Port Charles citizens have dressed in some fantastic costumes. Kevin is dressed as Sherlock Holmes and Eve is wearing what appears to be a very feminine Arabian garb, sort of like a genie. Eve persuades Kevin to take her to Ellen and Matt's party.
Lucy arrives at Scotty's house dressed as Cleopatra. Scotty's daughter greets Lucy at the door dressed as Little Bo Peep. She then proceeds to show Lucy the gag gifts that Neal gave her. She has itching powder and gum that turns the mouth black. Scotty dresses as a cool 50's dude in black leather. Lucy is concerned about going to the party since Scotty's character was killed at a costumed Mardi Gras.
Meanwhile, the killer injects poison into a shiny green apple intended for Scotty.
At the party, Julie arrives in a jailbird costume with Frank posing as Frankenstein. Matt and Ellen greet them as Dracula and Elvira. Chris, dressed up like Jason, is approached by Frank for more DL-57. Joe and Karen disguise themselves as Sir Lancelot and Guinevere. John arrives wearing the same costume as Joe.
Meanwhile, the killer places the poisoned apple in Scotty's bag.
Lucy overhears Eve and Kevin reminiscing about their dinner the other night. She decides to get revenge, so she places the itching powder in Kevin's coat and the gum in Kevin's bag of treats provided by Matt and Ellen.
Frank brought Julie a piece of chocolate. Eve examines the candy wrapper to make sure that it has not been tampered with. Frank asks her what she is doing, and she replies, "There are a lot of wackos that put things in candy that should not be there."
Eve eats a piece of gum out of Kevin's bag to find out that her mouth is black. Kevin puts on his jacket to go outside and begins to itch. Lucy watches deviously from the sidelines.
Scotty went into his bag and pulls out a shiny green apple. As he is about to bite into it, Ellen snatches the apple claiming a shortage in the dunking barrel. She places the green apple in the barrel and all of the children gather around. Neal is the first in line. Before Neal dunks his head, he says, "I'm going after the green one."