Garcia finds a voice disguising device at the Scanlon's and confronts Julie with it. She is the only one home, but she proclaims her innocence. Garcia arrests her and bring her to the PCPD station. Garcia calls Kevin and Victor and told them of the arrest. Kevin doesn't believe Julie is guilty and talks to her. She went into her usual tirade against Lark and claims Lark is the killer and is trying to frame her. Kevin then tries to talk to Lark who is very hostile towards him and ends the conversation by expressing her dislike and distrust of psychiatrists - Kevin looks thoughtful.
Lucy explains to Ellen that she was expecting Eve and wonders why Ellen is having a tryst with Kevin. Ellen angrily explains that she was there to meet Matt and the note was accidentally put in Eve's box. Ellen calls Matt and he explains about the flash floods making the roads dangerous. Meanwhile, Lucy tries to leave, but her car won't start. Ellen, who has cleaned herself up, lends Lucy her flannel nightshirt (which Lucy picks on) to sleep in and they prepare to share the bed. But since Lucy had used the nightshirt to wipe her hands with - it smells like fish guts and Ellen makes her sleep on the floor. The next morning, they find out that the bridge has been washed out by the rain and that they won't be able to leave.
Frank brought pictures of Lark, Victor, Chris, and Julie to the copy shop and asked the clerk if he recognized any of them. (In a nice bit of realism, the pictures are all different types instead of looking like they were all taken at the same time). The clerk looks through them and told Frank that all four had been customers at the shop.